I like this thread...
Crocodile vs. Mihawk... It probably has the potential of being an extremely epic fight...
I voted for Sir Crocodile over Hawkeye Mihawk
Mihawk went against three Devil Fruit users... Jozu, Crocodile, Buggy... and they all came out fine... I don't think he has CoA but he might... but until I see it, I won't say he has it...
Crocodile's effectiveness depends on location... and calmness... He was pissed off when lost against Luffy, and tried to defeat him without using his full potential to show his superority and that cost him the battle
If we really wanted to compare Luffy and Crocodile... it's Crocodile -- 2 and Luffy -- 1
Without a water source, or CoA comfirmed, I can't just give this to Mihawk... Luffy is basically a combat specialist by nature, he comes up with ingenius ways to use his abilities and his oponents abilities to the fullest, in an extended battle with Luffy nearly anybody is bound to have trouble...
and one more comparison between the 2 Shichibukai
Crocodile's Fights: Luffy, Countless ID gaurds including Demon Gaurds, Mihawk, Whitebeard, Whitebeard's Crew, Doflamigo, Jozu, Mihawk, and Akainu
Mihawks fights: Don Kriegs Armada, Shanks, Zoro, Luffy, Jozu, Vista, Mr. 1, Crocodile
Both are quite impressive...
though I am reluctant to change my vote... here is something you all should take heed of... though Crocodile took on Akainu and held his own for a bit... Mihawk has fought Shanks' swordsmanship evenly in the past, and Shanks stopped Akainu in his only official move in the war...
And one more thing... before we get to comparing them to the Yonkou's they fought, it was said Moria was even to Kaidou, and we know what the Strawhats/Mugiwaras did to him and his zombie army...