Croc vs Mihawk

who would win

  • Crocodile

    Votes: 19 23.8%
  • Mihawk

    Votes: 54 67.5%
  • can't decide

    Votes: 7 8.8%

  • Total voters
    80

MonsterEnvy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
733
Reaction score
207
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
So somehow people believe the greatest swordsman in the world would lose to a Silver Medalist who got the crap beaten out of him through most of the war?

If the only reason you're voting Crocodile is logia intangibility, then is Smoker also > Mihawk?

Mihawk would not be undone by Crocodile's slow attacks. Croc's two greatest attacks are Desert Spada (the sand blade that Luffy could punch into submission) and the tornado (forgot that one's name, might even have it mixed up. Anyway, it's a sandstorm that blows you away. Not exactly super damaging).

Forgive me for "lol"ing at "They fought equally in the war", because if one blade clash is all it takes then Aokoji = Zoro if all we had seen was their blades meet and then it had cut away to not show the obvious difference. Basically, we saw nothing. Crocodile clashed with half of the goddam war "equally", but he is not "equal" to Mihawk, Doflamingo, Jozu, Akainu, Luffy, etc.

P.S. Just because we haven't seen haki doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Please tell me where in the war you "saw" the Vice Admirals use haki, even though we obviously know they have it.
You think Croc is a sliver medalist if he was a sliver medalist he would not be a shichibukai at the war everyone reconized croc first

Croc was hit once by Jozu during the entire war he was not beaten up the entire war he took on Doflamingo and blew him and Jozu away fought with doflamingo and come out unscathled same with akainu and mihawk
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,470
Reaction score
25,031
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
People are seriously voting for crocodile? I am the first one to defend crocodile from people who claim he is weak in any way however saying he has so much as a shred of a chance against mihawk is absurd. Mihawk is difinitely a haki user and should by all intents and purposes be a damn good one at that. How else would he have been a rival to shanks or face vista (a confirmed haki user)? Crocodile is damn strong but in this scenario he is a tad out of his league IMO. Mihawk should be pretty much capable of cutting him. Even if crocodile's skill with his fruit makes him a threat for mihawk, he is still not going to have a chance.

Also, someone said mihawk should have been able to cut buggy with haki however that is not the case at all. Haki allows you to come in contact with logia's bodies however that logic does not work with buggy. Buggy's body was never intangible, physical contact has never been an issue. Thing is, haki does not cancel abilities, it merely allows contact as with a normal person (which is not an issue here). Thing is, even if buggy is cut with haki his ability would still be effective. Remember logia abilities make physical contact impossible and haki solves that.
 

MonsterEnvy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
733
Reaction score
207
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
People are seriously voting for crocodile? I am the first one to defend crocodile from people who claim he is weak in any way however saying he has so much as a shred of a chance against mihawk is absurd. Mihawk is difinitely a haki user and should by all intents and purposes be a damn good one at that. How else would he have been a rival to shanks or face vista (a confirmed haki user)? Crocodile is damn strong but in this scenario he is a tad out of his league IMO. Mihawk should be pretty much capable of cutting him. Even if crocodile's skill with his fruit makes him a threat for mihawk, he is still not going to have a chance.

Also, someone said mihawk should have been able to cut buggy with haki however that is not the case at all. Haki allows you to come in contact with logia's bodies however that logic does not work with buggy. Buggy's body was never intangible, physical contact has never been an issue. Thing is, haki does not cancel abilities, it merely allows contact as with a normal person (which is not an issue here). Thing is, even if buggy is cut with haki his ability would still be effective. Remember logia abilities make physical contact impossible and haki solves that.
normaly i agree with you but not this time

Croc is a top teir fighter the only wound he got the entire war was a scratch from Jozu punching him and he blew Jozu away after

Croc Clashed with Mihawk and told him off infact if croc so muched as touched mihawk he would be a mummy

here is a senario Crocs Hook clashes with Mihawks sword
Croc Turns his right arm into that sand blade that sucks the water out of anything it touchs and sucks Mihawk dry

when they clashed i saw fear in mihawks eyes

Croc can also throw a few sables at him and send him flying

If Mihawk had a Haki type then it would be Manta by my guess and you don't need haki to be strong Mihawks power i bet is pure skill
 

warriorofvirtue

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2009
Messages
439
Reaction score
78
Gender
Male
Country
United States
listen the guy took on whitebeard, akainu, jozu, mihawk and doflamingo. countless marines of various levels, and a kick from gear 2nd luffy come on give the man some credit. Also as i pointed out earlier he did all this not on his own turf!!!! theres nothin but ice and water around.
 

El-Thor

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2007
Messages
455
Reaction score
110
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I can't believe people are giving Mihawk so much credit. Granted I like his character, we never even saw the dude fight seriously.

Croc fought Whitebeard for g-d's sake !
 

vagabond87

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2009
Messages
1,678
Reaction score
1,212
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
Poland
I can't believe people are giving Mihawk so much credit. Granted I like his character, we never even saw the dude fight seriously.

Croc fought Whitebeard for g-d's sake !
Ummm..... Croc fought Whitebeard and what? He was defeated, probably lost an arm and was given big sacar over the face. He was crushed by Whitebeard.
Mihawk is stronger and in the end Croc would be dead if they fight... Its as simple as that.
 

MonsterEnvy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
733
Reaction score
207
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Ummm..... Croc fought Whitebeard and what? He was defeated, probably lost an arm and was given big sacar over the face. He was crushed by Whitebeard.
Mihawk is stronger and in the end Croc would be dead if they fight... Its as simple as that.
Mihawk would be Crushed by White beard and Croc was colmpeatly confedent he could beat whitebeard

Croc is also a guy that knows his limits and Hoesnestly it was never said that Whitebeard gave him the scar or loss of hand
 

frontaLobotomy

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2009
Messages
306
Reaction score
59
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
I think the main problem people are having with Crocodile was that the 2 big fights we have known him to have, he has lost in. To be fair, one was Whitebeard, the other is the Manga's protagonist. He didn't stand much of a chance when you think about it. Mihawk didn't try to kill Crocodile in Marineford when he stood off against him, or he didn't succeed in trying if he did. They're evenly matched power wise, at least that's how I see it. While Mihawk can beat Luffy, he could lose to Buggy. One Piece is weird like that.
 

St Michael

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2010
Messages
166
Reaction score
34
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
France
Also, someone said mihawk should have been able to cut buggy with haki however that is not the case at all. Haki allows you to come in contact with logia's bodies however that logic does not work with buggy. Buggy's body was never intangible, physical contact has never been an issue. Thing is, haki does not cancel abilities, it merely allows contact as with a normal person (which is not an issue here). Thing is, even if buggy is cut with haki his ability would still be effective. Remember logia abilities make physical contact impossible and haki solves that.
I agree with the first half of you post (which I didn't quoted) but the second sounds weird to me.

If haki makes Luffy's rubber body normal (in taking damage at least) , why it isn't working with Buggy ?

I won't pretend Mihawk can't use haki , I think the opposite , however I don't think he had imbued his blade with COA (or whatever is the name) at that moment. Remember that the hit was meant to Luffy , blades cut Luffy hakized or not , so ..

Anyway , it doesn't matter.

Bittman , Crocodile isn't weak. Weaker than Mihawk , probably , weak not.
Doflamingo can't beat him (otherwise he would have at least hurt him) , Jozu seems a bit stronger , he is superior to Luffy (pre TS) and Aka Inu is even stronger than Mihawk. But you can treat him as a trash like Mr 3 , Tashigi or fodder.
He's in the top 20 most powerful char seen so far .. If I didn't count wrong :D
 

MonsterEnvy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
733
Reaction score
207
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
I think the main problem people are having with Crocodile was that the 2 big fights we have known him to have, he has lost in. To be fair, one was Whitebeard, the other is the Manga's protagonist. He didn't stand much of a chance when you think about it. Mihawk didn't try to kill Crocodile in Marineford when he stood off against him, or he didn't succeed in trying if he did. They're evenly matched power wise, at least that's how I see it. While Mihawk can beat Luffy, he could lose to Buggy. One Piece is weird like that.
largely agree with you but your forgot one thing Croc crushed Luffy in their first 2 fights with out any real problems then in the 3rd fight its more of a draw Luffy manged to knock him out (because Croc felt like beating Luffy the old fasonion way instead of using his broken powers untill it was too late) and still pumped luffy full of posion that was going to kill luffy if robin had not saved him

if robin was not there croc would have lived and luffy died i thing it was a draw
 

Judau Ashta

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2008
Messages
107
Reaction score
24
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
The point of being a swordsman is not being hit. If the greatest couldn't dodge/evade someone like Croc (who couldn't catch Jozu without Doflamingo there), then why is he called the greatest? Might as well kick Shanks out of the yonkou too since the "greatest" doesn't have interest in fighting him anymore. Imo, this can just be a draw. Neither being able to hit each other unless Mihawk knows coa haki.
 

MonsterEnvy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
733
Reaction score
207
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
The point of being a swordsman is not being hit. If the greatest couldn't dodge/evade someone like Croc (who couldn't catch Jozu without Doflamingo there), then why is he called the greatest? Might as well kick Shanks out of the yonkou too since the "greatest" doesn't have interest in fighting him anymore. Imo, this can just be a draw. Neither being able to hit each other unless Mihawk knows coa haki.
You honestly think that Croc could not hit Mihawk

Mihawk nearly gets hit in every fight he just blocks the attack and Lots of Crocs Attacks can't be blocked

Crocodile did not try to hit Jozu until Doflamingo started talking and its really hard to miss with Sables

your also forgetting that Mihawks Strongest Slash could not cut Jozu
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,470
Reaction score
25,031
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
I agree with the first half of you post (which I didn't quoted) but the second sounds weird to me.

If haki makes Luffy's rubber body normal (in taking damage at least) , why it isn't working with Buggy ?

I won't pretend Mihawk can't use haki , I think the opposite , however I don't think he had imbued his blade with COA (or whatever is the name) at that moment. Remember that the hit was meant to Luffy , blades cut Luffy hakized or not , so ..

Anyway , it doesn't matter.

Bittman , Crocodile isn't weak. Weaker than Mihawk , probably , weak not.
Doflamingo can't beat him (otherwise he would have at least hurt him) , Jozu seems a bit stronger , he is superior to Luffy (pre TS) and Aka Inu is even stronger than Mihawk. But you can treat him as a trash like Mr 3 , Tashigi or fodder.
He's in the top 20 most powerful char seen so far .. If I didn't count wrong :D
I know it is confusing however there is one thing to get clear here. Haki DOES NOT nullify DF abilities. I guess the best way to describe the effect of haki is to allow or improve contact as with a normal body(luffy does not stop being rubber when he is hit with haki for instance, attacks just have a better effect). Thing about buggy is that anyone can already cut him as with a normal body. Since his DF allows him to split his body then even haki imbued cuts won't kill him either. The case with buggy and luffy are inherently different. Buggy's ability won't be canceled by haki. Not to mention swords cut buggy the same whether there is haki or not.

As for crocodile's fight with mihawk, we barely saw a second of it. All we saw was crocodile blocking 1 attack. That said, mihawk survived the war with no wounds, contrary to crocodile who was seen bleeding and whatnot even though he was a logia.
 

St Michael

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2010
Messages
166
Reaction score
34
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
France
Ok your explanation seems plausible to me .. if you're right Buggy got himself a nice DF.

But I have to say that it would disappoint me , I'ld prefer that haki works on him .. whatever. Only Oda knows the truth (for now) :p

Yes Mihawk was unharmed , Croc a bit less. But it's not like he fought a lot of big names .. Croc excluded , he attacked a Luffy who barely defended himself (not if he could have actually won nonetheless) and Vista. Plus fodder.
And we have seen where Croc got his wound --> Jozu falcon punch.

If they actually fought a bit , none of them hit/hurt the other.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,470
Reaction score
25,031
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
Ok your explanation seems plausible to me .. if you're right Buggy got himself a nice DF.

But I have to say that it would disappoint me , I'ld prefer that haki works on him .. whatever. Only Oda knows the truth (for now) :p

Yes Mihawk was unharmed , Croc a bit less. But it's not like he fought a lot of big names .. Croc excluded , he attacked a Luffy who barely defended himself (not if he could have actually won nonetheless) and Vista. Plus fodder.
And we have seen where Croc got his wound --> Jozu falcon punch.

If they actually fought a bit , none of them hit/hurt the other.
Buggy has one of the most hax fruits around, if he actually had any strength he'd be an epic fighter lol. That said, I am not saying haki does not work on him but rather that haki does not work as most people assume it does.

Mihawk had a reasonably long confrontation with vista, someone who evidently stands on the same ground as marco or jozu and mihawk still had no signs of injuries. I don't think crocodile's confrontation with jozu, flamingo or mihawk were long in the least and he was still seemingly wounded.
 

Ero-Sanji

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jun 25, 2009
Messages
3,197
Reaction score
2,557
Gender
Male
Country
Sweden
I don't agree with the Buggy thing.

I think Rayleigh pretty much said Haki makes you hit the un-hit-able and cut the un-cut-able.

Anyway, I think Mihawk got this. Crocoboy is good but Mihawk is better. Think about it Mihawk fought evenly with Shanks a Haki powerhouse, there's no doubt that he too can use it. Therefor Crocoboy is quite in a mess.
 

MonsterEnvy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
733
Reaction score
207
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
I don't agree with the Buggy thing.

I think Rayleigh pretty much said Haki makes you hit the un-hit-able and cut the un-cut-able.

Anyway, I think Mihawk got this. Crocoboy is good but Mihawk is better. Think about it Mihawk fought evenly with Shanks a Haki powerhouse, there's no doubt that he too can use it. Therefor Crocoboy is quite in a mess.
just because he fought with some one with Haki does not mean he can use it and if he does use it i bet its Mantra not COA plus how is Mihawk going to defend agienst Sables

and Kilck Croc was only hurt by Jozu and Had tottal confadance he could beat Mihawk all he gas to do is use the sand sword that drains the water out of you
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,470
Reaction score
25,031
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
just because he fought with some one with Haki does not mean he can use it and if he does use it i bet its Mantra not COA plus how is Mihawk going to defend agienst Sables

and Kilck Croc was only hurt by Jozu and Had tottal confadance he could beat Mihawk all he gas to do is use the sand sword that drains the water out of you
I would think mihawk could simply cut through crocodile's tornadoes and reach him. I think the bigger question here is how exactly crocodile would ultimately defend himself from mihawk. Mihawk's swordmanship is deadly at all ranges and I would think mihawks range is actually quite superior to that of crocodile. Sabers would definitely be a game winner here however this is a problem. Mihawk is without a shred of a doubt infinitely faster than crocodile. Crocodile's speed is not even that of gear 2 luffy. Given that, how could crocodile ever connect a hit to mihawk? I don't think it is possible.

I don't agree with the Buggy thing.

I think Rayleigh pretty much said Haki makes you hit the un-hit-able and cut the un-cut-able.
buggy is not uncuttable nor unhittable though. Quite the opposite. His ability simply allows his to section his own body and put it back together.
 

Wisshard

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2010
Messages
130
Reaction score
38
Gender
Male
Country
Sweden
Thing about buggy is that anyone can already cut him as with a normal body. Since his DF allows him to split his body then even haki imbued cuts won't kill him either..
CoA gives you the ability to bypass Devil Fruit induced properties and touch their real body. Consequently, if Mihawk cut Buggy with a CoA imbued slash, then Buggy's real body would be cut.

That being said, the whole scene with Mihawk and Buggy had a feel of comic relief to it, from Buggy getting chopped up into a couple of thousand pieces in an instant by Mihawk, to Buggy's hilarious face when his Muggy Ball detonated in his face. Thus, I wouldn't read too much into it if I were you.

You honestly think that Croc could not hit Mihawk
Yes. Considering Crocodile's combat speed is about on par with Arabasta Luffy, while Mihawk's combat speed exceeds Marinford G2 Luffy.

your also forgetting that Mihawks Strongest Slash could not cut Jozu
Mihawk is the strongest swordsman, and in keeping of his title, everything that he does with his sword can be called the strongest. Hence, I wouldn't really take that name-less fodder's words at face value...

That being said, Jozu is one of the most prominent Whitebeard Commanders and his forte is defense, considering his Diamond fruit. Thus, it doesn't diminish Mihawk in any way that Jozu was able to block one attack from him.

OP@, even if we assume that Mihawk doesn't possess CoA (which is extremely likely), the difference in combat speed is far to great and Mihawk should be able to figure out that liquid solidify sand eventually (if he doesn't know it already). Once Mihawk has some liquid on his blade (tears, blood, water or w/e), Crocodile is done for.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
Mihawk has never shown the use of COA haki or else he would have sliced Buggy for real
Marco and Vista attacked Akainu with Haki, but did not sliced him... We don't know how Haki works in details, we can't just say who has or not Haki.

Haki is not a secret society. The priests know how to use it. The Kuja know how to use it. And even Hacchi, subordinate of the good old Arlong, has knowledge of Haki.

So I don't see why expect that guys like Mihawk, Crocodile or Moria who have confronted the Yonkou in the past can't use it.
 
Top