Conditional Mirajane vs Brandish

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
2,049
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
Gray confirmed they have more training and stronger magic so that would be a factor. It could be that those affected were caught off guard or what not, that does have a factor in a fight against stronger enemies too like August, Brandish, Jose, etc.. Mira said that she commanded everyone, so all the grunts present would be affected. Macro does not work on Demons before 100YQ, so Mira would be strong enough to affect them now. It did not work on Laxus before because of his different mindset under the influence of the White Wizard. Brandish and Daemon are roughly around the same level given how their powers can affect Dragon Gods. Given how Macro is used a lot when enemies are off guard, that would explain it’s affectiveness. Which would add to why that will not work in this fight since Brandish knows about it via Zeref.
Gray said they were stronger than Avatar grunts. Nothing about Erza, Elfman, Minerva from a year back and nothing about them being stronger than the ones Mira commanded since he's actually refering to the ones Mira commanded since he said this before Mirajane used macro.

Mira said I command you all to sleep and then said I guess these are the ones they'll have to beat up. Nothing implies or states that the grunts in the back were stronger than the ones in front and resisted her by training or actively defending. We just know it did not work. Saying 1 faceless grunt is stronger than the others isn't really shown. A limit on the numbers is still a viable reason.

Laxus can be affected by Kyria
Erza can be affected by Brandish,
Brandish can be affected by Mest.
Why would Mira fail to control Brandish?

This is current Mira, Brandish and Daemon in 100 years quest I'm talking about so again bringing up Alvarez grunts fail to prove anything,

Nothing in canon indicates being aware of macro blocks it. It's not hypnosis. It's a curse that controls them against their will. You are making up a condition. Macro has never been stated to or implied to be effective because you catch someone off guard.

Logically because macro has no canon counter with power level being great or being aware AND Mira scales to current Laxus, we have little reason to believe Brandish is immune. Mest's memory alteration worked on her.
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,034
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Gray said they were stronger than Avatar grunts. Nothing about Erza, Elfman, Minerva from a year back and nothing about them being stronger than the ones Mira commanded since he's actually refering to the ones Mira commanded since he said this before Mirajane used macro.

Mira said I command you all to sleep and then said I guess these are the ones they'll have to beat up. Nothing implies or states that the grunts in the back were stronger than the ones in front and resisted her by training or actively defending. We just know it did not work. Saying 1 faceless grunt is stronger than the others isn't really shown. A limit on the numbers is still a viable reason.

Laxus can be affected by Kyria
Erza can be affected by Brandish,
Brandish can be affected by Mest.
Why would Mira fail to control Brandish?

This is current Mira, Brandish and Daemon in 100 years quest I'm talking about so again bringing up Alvarez grunts fail to prove anything,

Nothing in canon indicates being aware of macro blocks it. It's not hypnosis. It's a curse that controls them against their will. You are making up a condition. Macro has never been stated to or implied to be effective because you catch someone off guard.

Logically because macro has no canon counter with power level being great or being aware AND Mira scales to current Laxus, we have little reason to believe Brandish is immune. Mest's memory alteration worked on her.
That doesn’t change the fact they are strong, that they could easily damage someone like Natsu, that doesn’t imply it related to numbers as well since she said “everyone”, it would be all her enemies in the range of her FOE, and she can cover hundreds of meters. It is common strategy to send in fodder first to weaken your enemies with better via Wall, again, it would be a matter of being aware of the ability happening to take effect, mental fortitude is a factor in those kinds of powers afterall. Laxus did not get affected by Kyria since he had a different mindset prior. Brandish had equal or greater magic Than Erza. Brandish was not aware as Memory magic as Mest used stealth like illusion or mind powers like that are weak to awareness. It is still relevant as it comes down to if they are aware or not of Macro affecting them, those grunts who were affected were likely not paying attention to her at the time and the others did resisted, Mira did not become fatigue from the numbers affected either as it does drain power like how Mira gained Macro from Seliah drained her stamina. It is not about power level, it is about mental strength and being aware of it. Again, Mest worked on Brandish because she was not paying attention to him and it is stated memory fails with awareness.
 

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
2,049
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
That doesn’t change the fact they are strong, that they could easily damage someone like Natsu, that doesn’t imply it related to numbers as well since she said “everyone”, it would be all her enemies in the range of her FOE, and she can cover hundreds of meters. It is common strategy to send in fodder first to weaken your enemies with better via Wall, again, it would be a matter of being aware of the ability happening to take effect, mental fortitude is a factor in those kinds of powers afterall. Laxus did not get affected by Kyria since he had a different mindset prior. Brandish had equal or greater magic Than Erza. Brandish was not aware as Memory magic as Mest used stealth like illusion or mind powers like that are weak to awareness. It is still relevant as it comes down to if they are aware or not of Macro affecting them, those grunts who were affected were likely not paying attention to her at the time and the others did resisted, Mira did not become fatigue from the numbers affected either as it does drain power like how Mira gained Macro from Seliah drained her stamina. It is not about power level, it is about mental strength and being aware of it. Again, Mest worked on Brandish because she was not paying attention to him and it is stated memory fails with awareness.

Mental fortitude was not shown to be a factor for Macro and even if it was random soldier fodder having that ability when Erza and Elfman a year before didn't have it and Daemon a year after also lacked it makes 0 sense. Mashima has still not shown a confirmed counter for macro. Funny enough he makes Mira just not use it instead of having it fail. You also do not know if Brandish is one of those who can even break out of it if that is the case. We also do not know if the alvarez soldiers defended against it or Mira could've only used it on some of them simultaneously.

Laxus got affected by Kyria the 2nd time because there was no white witch and barely managed to break out because Lucy was going to die. Nothing of that sort happened to those random soldiers. Even if awareness helps against hypnosis which is what Erza told us, macro is not hypnotic magic. It is a curse that controls.

Mira literaly absorbed Seilah's power via takeover which is how there was a drain in power.

Your assumption that Brandish would just break out of macro because she is allegedly aware of it and because some Alvarez fodder of dozens weren't affected at the same time, lacks canon backing.

Mirajane is also the strongest version of herself now hence her macro working on Daemon and her Alegria and Thorn curse keeping up with Elexion Soul powered Laxus so the assumption that her curses like macro would fail on Brandish who is likely weaker than her makes little sense.

It's also using a lot of assumptions i.e. Brandish can break out due to mental power; Brandish knows about macro; Alvarez soldiers defended themselves somehow while the others fell; Brandish can instantly avoid macro without struggle before Mira ends her.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

- Mira is on par with current Laxus
-Brandish was on par with or weaker than Laxus a year ago (unlikely she powered up beyond him now)
-Macro worked easily on Daemon a few chapters ago
-Brandish has no feat or hype of countering macro
-Macro is not hypnosis so has no canon proof of awareness weakening it
-Nothing proved Alvarez fodder focussed and blocked macro while dozens of their friends fell for it at the same time
-Alvarez grunts has no prep time to focus since she used it on the whole crowd
-Macro worked on Tartaros Erza in Tartaros, Daemon in 100 years quest and numerous Alvarez lackies in Alvarez.
-Mira's Alegria curses are still relevant and thorn curse is on par with Elexion Soul Laxus' lightning.
-Brandish's hax worked on Mira and Erza in 100 years quest and she's their equal or inferior power wise.

Nothing here indicates Brandish is immune to macro but Mira would get one shot by her powers.
 
Last edited:

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,034
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Mental fortitude was not shown to be a factor for Macro and even if it was random soldier fodder having that ability when Erza and Elfman a year before didn't have it and Daemon a year after also lacked it makes 0 sense. Mashima has still not shown a confirmed counter for macro. Funny enough he makes Mira just not use it instead of having it fail. You also do not know if Brandish is one of those who can even break out of it if that is the case. We also do not know if the alvarez soldiers defended against it or Mira could've only used it on some of them simultaneously.

Laxus got affected by Kyria the 2nd time because there was no white witch and barely managed to break out because Lucy was going to die. Nothing of that sort happened to those random soldiers. Even if awareness helps against hypnosis which is what Erza told us, macro is not hypnotic magic. It is a curse that controls.

Mira literaly absorbed Seilah's power via takeover which is how there was a drain in power.

Your assumption that Brandish would just break out of macro because she is allegedly aware of it and because some Alvarez fodder of dozens weren't affected at the same time, lacks canon backing.

Mirajane is also the strongest version of herself now hence her macro working on Daemon and her Alegria and Thorn curse keeping up with Elexion Soul powered Laxus so the assumption that her curses like macro would fail on Brandish who is likely weaker than her makes little sense.

It's also using a lot of assumptions i.e. Brandish can break out due to mental power; Brandish knows about macro; Alvarez soldiers defended themselves somehow while the others fell; Brandish can instantly avoid macro without struggle before Mira ends her.
Given that Elfman retained his mental state trying to resist prior to blowing up FT and his eyes were normal, after he decided he was going to his eyes changed, that would be the factor of mental fortitude. Again, they didn’t know about that power so they would likely not be ready for it, which any mental based power is hard to counter if they are not aware of it. Considering it is likely a non-factor going forward, and Seliah form should not exist since Zeref was dead and all his demons should be dead too, 100YQ is known for it’s retcons Afterall. Considering Wall was there and fully aware of the existence of Macro via Zeref, no reason Brandish wouldn’t know either. Considering they were in the middle of battle with other FT members makes them more than likely not pay attention, considering her wording includes all of them so it is not a one at a time thing. It was still a different mind set as stated that WW magic makes them personally different than before, and cutting works like illusion, weak to awareness. Those would be ones that likely paid attention to her And not on the other wizards, it can still be resisted as Elfman showed us which via visuals. That power was Macro which requires energy, which would be evident if it was a number issue then Mira would be drained of power by then, just like with the issue with numbers via Fairy Law. Brandish works under Zeref, she knows his history, Wall demonstrated to be aware of it too, again those soldiers would be distracted fighting other FT members. sure it MIGHT work now given her battle with Daemon but not absolutely as Brandish‘s power was strong enough to harm a DG, again, those soldiers were busy fighting while the others likely paid attention to her. Laxus struggled to put down base Wall who was the weakest Spriggan (And Laxus’ strength is equal to his MP) before his sickness hampered him. Elfman was mentally controlled by Macro so it does have mental powers. Those other soldiers were busy fighting to not pay attention, Wall was not affected either. Mira was not drained of power by numbers. Those who weren’t in front would have prep time since they were not fighting yet. Erza who was distracted. Daemon did not know about Macro and those Alvarez grunts were busy fighting. Not that impressive against an enemy weaker than a full powered DG, considering her power level can harm a DG, I doubt that at this point. Given that it showed resistance is a factor via eyes and that Mira did not get tired out via numbers she affected, Macro can be resisted and Brandish would be no exception.
 

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
2,049
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
Given that Elfman retained his mental state trying to resist prior to blowing up FT and his eyes were normal, after he decided he was going to his eyes changed, that would be the factor of mental fortitude. Again, they didn’t know about that power so they would likely not be ready for it, which any mental based power is hard to counter if they are not aware of it. Considering it is likely a non-factor going forward, and Seliah form should not exist since Zeref was dead and all his demons should be dead too, 100YQ is known for it’s retcons Afterall.
Again you have no character breaking out of it with mental fortitude. Elfman and Erza were not hypnotised and resisted but Seilah calmly stood back and they failed. Claiming Brandish would break out of it vs Current Mirajane has no backing especially when Mira is above any form of Seilah and likely above Brandish herself.

Does Brandish even know about Macro in the first place?

Seilah form not existing was never rooted in canon. It's again a headcanon being touted as a logical conclusion. Mirajane used takeover on Tartaros before Zeref died. That power was hers, she became one with them and made it her own. Nothing to do with Zeref.

It's a non factor but Mirajane used it successfully vs Daemon recently. Ok?

Considering Wall was there and fully aware of the existence of Macro via Zeref, no reason Brandish wouldn’t know either. Considering they were in the middle of battle with other FT members makes them more than likely not pay attention, considering her wording includes all of them so it is not a one at a time thing. It was still a different mind set as stated that WW magic makes them personally different than before, and cutting works like illusion, weak to awareness.
There you go again. This is all assumptions and headcanon. Wall who analyses weaknesses and is basically a computer knowing about macro doesn't mean Brandish would know.

Those would be ones that likely paid attention to her And not on the other wizards, it can still be resisted as Elfman showed us which via visuals. That power was Macro which requires energy, which would be evident if it was a number issue then Mira would be drained of power by then, just like with the issue with numbers via Fairy Law.
If the fodder were too strong for Macro it would have shocked Mira. Not have her smile at the fact that she gets to beat them up. It being a numbers issue makes perfect sense since they were ALL FODDER and it worked on a lot but not all. Same enemies. You're trying to headcanon strong Alvarez soldiers dressed, acting and fighting identically as weak soldiers and doing some OP defensive meditation to counter macro OFF PANEL.

Brandish works under Zeref, she knows his history, Wall demonstrated to be aware of it too, again those soldiers would be distracted fighting other FT members. sure it MIGHT work now given her battle with Daemon but not absolutely as Brandish‘s power was strong enough to harm a DG, again, those soldiers were busy fighting while the others likely paid attention to her. Laxus struggled to put down base Wall who was the weakest Spriggan (And Laxus’ strength is equal to his MP) before his sickness hampered him.
Brandish working under Zeref doesn't mean she knows every detail of his life; she knows about macro and she knows Mira has macro.
Daemon literally hurt a Dragon God too.

Elfman was mentally controlled by Macro so it does have mental powers. Those other soldiers were busy fighting to not pay attention, Wall was not affected either. Mira was not drained of power by numbers. Those who weren’t in front would have prep time since they were not fighting yet.
Elfman was going to kill Lisanna and that mental boost did nothing to stop him. Is there a greater bolster for 'mental fortitude' for a Strauss sibling?

Why would Mira have to be drained of power if she could theoretically only use macro on X number of people at once?

Prep time for what? You keep saying they resisted and prepared for macro. How could they when she spoke to all of them together? The speed the sound of her voice traveled from the front to the back and in that gap they started their counter? They moved faster than her voice traveled?

Erza who was distracted. Daemon did not know about Macro and those Alvarez grunts were busy fighting. Not that impressive against an enemy weaker than a full powered DG, considering her power level can harm a DG, I doubt that at this point. Given that it showed resistance is a factor via eyes and that Mira did not get tired out via numbers she affected, Macro can be resisted and Brandish would be no exception.
-Daemon hurt Aldoron and macro worked on her fine.
-There is no evidence distraction helps macro work.
-No evidence it's hypnosis that can be resisted by awareness.
Resistance factor via eyes? Lol they were not hypnotised, their body was controlled against their will. Clearly they would try to resist and show their stuggle shown in their eyes.
-You're using ONLY headcanons.

We have 0 evidence that Brandish, who is weaker than Mira can resist macro. Mira scales to current Laxus.
 
Last edited:

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,034
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Again you have no character breaking out of it with mental fortitude. Elfman and Erza were not hypnotised and resisted but Seilah calmly stood back and they failed. Claiming Brandish would break out of it vs Current Mirajane has no backing especially when Mira is above any form of Seilah and likely above Brandish herself.

Does Brandish even know about Macro in the first place?

Seilah form not existing was never rooted in canon. It's again a headcanon being touted as a logical conclusion. Mirajane used takeover on Tartaros before Zeref died. That power was hers, she became one with them and made it her own. Nothing to do with Zeref.

It's a non factor but Mirajane used it successfully vs Daemon recently. Ok?



There you go again. This is all assumptions and headcanon. Wall who analyses weaknesses and is basically a computer knowing about macro doesn't mean Brandish would know.



If the fodder were too strong for Macro it would have shocked Mira. Not have her smile at the fact that she gets to beat them up. It being a numbers issue makes perfect sense since they were ALL FODDER and it worked on a lot but not all. Same enemies. You're trying to headcanon strong Alvarez soldiers dressed, acting and fighting identically as weak soldiers and doing some OP defensive meditation to counter macro OFF PANEL.



Brandish working under Zeref doesn't mean she knows every detail of his life; she knows about macro and she knows Mira has macro.
Daemon literally hurt a Dragon God too.



Elfman was going to kill Lisanna and that mental boost did nothing to stop him. Is there a greater bolster for 'mental fortitude' for a Strauss sibling?


Why would Mira have to be drained of power if she could theoretically only use macro on X number of people at once?

Prep time for what? You keep saying they resisted and prepared for macro. How could they when she spoke to all of them together? The speed the sound of her voice traveled from the front to the back and in that gap they started their counter? They moved faster than her voice traveled?



-Daemon hurt Aldoron and macro worked on her fine.
-There is no evidence distraction helps macro work.
-No evidence it's hypnosis that can be resisted by awareness.
Resistance factor via eyes? Lol they were not hypnotised, their body was controlled against their will. Clearly they would try to resist and show their stuggle shown in their eyes.
-You're using ONLY headcanons.

We have 0 evidence that Brandish, who is weaker than Mira can resist macro. Mira scales to current Laxus.
That just shows Elfman and Erza at the time had weaker resistance than the Alvarez soldiers. all this makes it sound like NLF as it makes it sound like Macro can work on the likes of Acnologia or the Five Dragon Gods. I would say that Mira would have scaled to Brandish given her feat against Daemon, however after her struggle against A CB dragon, I am not so sure.Yes given she knows about Zeref’s history and demons that tried to kill him. and Tartaros is still a demon of Zeref which was stated when Zeref dies, anything related to him dies too. Similarly to Natsu not being entirely a demon as he is a human with a demon’s power. Wall never created a Weakness soldier from it nor did he showed visuals of him analyzing Macro which he changes his form for, he just stood back there knowing it was something related to Zeref calling them one of his play toys. Lisanna and Gray was surprised for the both of them, besides Mira is a sadist so she gets to enjoy beating them up, it is not like they couldn’t handle the situation, just more effort to put in. If it were numbers, she would have been drained of power instantly since it requires energy. Doesn’t make all Of them equal whether it be skills, power or circumstances, just like how being aware of a mind controlling power has limits with it. It was on panel, she included everyone so even those in the back would be affected. They know about Natsu being END, something even Tartaros did not even know. Iwill refer to Daemon part to my earlier quote above. It prevented him from killing his sister sooner, it is for anyone really that shows it, Erza, Elfman, MInerva, etc.. Since it uses her own power makes anyone fatigue as Seilah showed when she lost her power. Not all of them were fighting, meaning those who weren’t would be more than able to be prepared. Alvarez grunts were able to hurt Natsu and he can dodge lightning and that is hundreds to thousands of times faster than sound. Mental powers =/= MP, hence why Memory can work on even stronger characters who are not aware of it. Erza and gang were distracted trying to stop Face. None of those aware were mentally compelled other than Elfman who gave in later on, he was literally spouting for FT to die while under the influence via eyes. There is nothing suggesting Macro being all powerful either, that is NLF. Mira and Laxus Struggled against CB dragons, while Brandish with her power could overpower a full power DG. After current displays, it seems these demons of Faris are not totally strong via scaling.
 
Last edited:

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
2,049
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
That just shows Elfman and Erza at the time had weaker resistance than the Alvarez soldiers. all this makes it sound like NLF as it makes it sound like Macro can work on the likes of Acnologia or the Five Dragon Gods. I would say that Mira would have scaled to Brandish given her feat against Daemon, however after her struggle against A CB dragon, I am not so sure.Yes given she knows about Zeref’s history and demons that tried to kill him. and Tartaros is still a demon of Zeref which was stated when Zeref dies, anything related to him dies too. Similarly to Natsu not being entirely a demon as he is a human with a demon’s power. Wall never created a Weakness soldier from it nor did he showed visuals of him analyzing Macro which he changes his form for, he just stood back there knowing it was something related to Zeref calling them one of his play toys. Lisanna and Gray was surprised for the both of them, besides Mira is a sadist so she gets to enjoy beating them up, it is not like they couldn’t handle the situation, just more effort to put in. If it were numbers, she would have been drained of power instantly since it requires energy. Doesn’t make all Of them equal whether it be skills, power or circumstances, just like how being aware of a mind controlling power has limits with it. It was on panel, she included everyone so even those in the back would be affected. They know about Natsu being END, something even Tartaros did not even know. Iwill refer to Daemon part to my earlier quote above. It prevented him from killing his sister sooner, it is for anyone really that shows it, Erza, Elfman, MInerva, etc.. Since it uses her own power makes anyone fatigue as Seilah showed when she lost her power. Not all of them were fighting, meaning those who weren’t would be more than able to be prepared. Alvarez grunts were able to hurt Natsu and he can dodge lightning and that is hundreds to thousands of times faster than sound. Mental powers =/= MP, hence why Memory can work on even stronger characters who are not aware of it. Erza and gang were distracted trying to stop Face. None of those aware were mentally compelled other than Elfman who gave in later on, he was literally spouting for FT to die while under the influence via eyes. There is nothing suggesting Macro being all powerful either, that is NLF. Mira and Laxus Struggled against CB dragons, while Brandish with her power could overpower a full power DG. After current displays, it seems these demons of Faris are not totally strong via scaling.
No you are making a false comparison between Macro working on Brandish who is a regular human who is below Mira and Acnologia who is still arguably the strongest character in the series.

Brandish has no proof of knowing everything about Zeref, Burden of proof is on you to prove that Brandish knows about all tartaros curses AND that Mira has them.

What do you mean her struggle against a CB? Are you implying that makes her below Brandish? Well then Laxus and Erza are below Brandish too then since Mira scaled directly to them and even equaled Laxus' attack, durability AND reaction time. Plus her physical feat of ragdolling scissor runner scales above him and Erza's slashing/brawling feats vs CBs. Laxus was on par with or beyond Brandish a year ago so she is not stronger than him even if her hax works on him.

No it would not mean she would be drained of energy. If there is a limit to how many people a spell can work on then that's the limit. It's not her able to use all her curse power to reach as many as possible. Two different things altogether.

Seilah got weaker because Mira was taking her over i.e. taking her curse power as her own. Nothing about this is proving Brandish is immune to Mira's macro. Like???

What do you mean more than prepared? She used macro on all of them at the same time. How did some prepare and some did not? You are basing all of this on your headcanon, opinions and biases.

Oh here comes the Mira downplay via Faris demons. Elfman needed the power of a dragon God in his arm to beat one and Mira beat one with Alegria so clearly they are strong. They beat oracion Seis and gave Gajeel issues also.

Brandish did not beat a Dragon God and Mira herself overpowered scissor runner when she flung him so her physical strength boosted by Wendy is beyond Brandish's. We can't say Mira is weaker or Brandish is physically stronger as one had Wendy and did better and one didn't.

Brandish is a regular spriggan. Laxus/Mira/Erza/Jellal are on the level or above.
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,034
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
No you are making a false comparison between Macro working on Brandish who is a regular human who is below Mira and Acnologia who is still arguably the strongest character in the series.

Brandish has no proof of knowing everything about Zeref, Burden of proof is on you to prove that Brandish knows about all tartaros curses AND that Mira has them.

What do you mean her struggle against a CB? Are you implying that makes her below Brandish? Well then Laxus and Erza are below Brandish too then since Mira scaled directly to them and even equaled Laxus' attack, durability AND reaction time. Plus her physical feat of ragdolling scissor runner scales above him and Erza's slashing/brawling feats vs CBs. Laxus was on par with or beyond Brandish a year ago so she is not stronger than him even if her hax works on him.

No it would not mean she would be drained of energy. If there is a limit to how many people a spell can work on then that's the limit. It's not her able to use all her curse power to reach as many as possible. Two different things altogether.

Seilah got weaker because Mira was taking her over i.e. taking her curse power as her own. Nothing about this is proving Brandish is immune to Mira's macro. Like???

What do you mean more than prepared? She used macro on all of them at the same time. How did some prepare and some did not? You are basing all of this on your headcanon, opinions and biases.

Oh here comes the Mira downplay via Faris demons. Elfman needed the power of a dragon God in his arm to beat one and Mira beat one with Alegria so clearly they are strong. They beat oracion Seis and gave Gajeel issues also.

Brandish did not beat a Dragon God and Mira herself overpowered scissor runner when she flung him so her physical strength boosted by Wendy is beyond Brandish's. We can't say Mira is weaker or Brandish is physically stronger as one had Wendy and did better and one didn't.

Brandish is a regular spriggan. Laxus/Mira/Erza/Jellal are on the level or above.
You are making it sound like Macro can work on anything, by that logic it should work on Acno, which begs to ask, why didn’t it. But Brandish managed to shrink Mira so Mira can’t be stronger. Brandish worked with Zeref, August and anyone in Alvarez knows about Zeref’s curse, Dimaria knew about Natsu being END and Wall knew about Mavis being Zeref’s lover as well, there is no way Brandish wouldn’t know about Tartaros’ fully knowing they were made to kill him. Heck they literally had a Spriggan member with all the curses from Tartaros! Zeref has had tabs on everyone in Fairy Tail as with his conversation with Gray. Yes because even Erza had to use a part of Irene’s power to beat one of them. Stats are determined by MP afterall, Laxus struggled against Wall who was the weakest tier in the Spriggans, even though his lightning was inaffective, his physical power matches in power and he still struggled, her power is based on MPL afterall. There is no confirmation of it being numbers, and yes that would mean limit in numbers based drainage since it costs one power to use, no different from Fairy Law which has a limit on targets via one’s own power. It was explicitly stated the power drain via taking her Macro, meaning it is the ability itself that has energy. It shows that using it has an energy limit which would have been shown if there is a limit to number of people. Like how Aera explicitly stated to have a limit of one person Exceeds can carry and it drains their power, so yes, numbers do factor into draining power. Not all of them were busy fighting at the moment so they couldn’t be prepared, like there are people in the back who are still fresh, that is a fact, that is the point. Eflman could only do a partial take over so he didn’t get all of it’s power, only that which he can handle, again, even with Alegria, Mira is still struggling against CB which should not be the case if with Daemon who could melt the body of Aldoron. Gajeel was defeated by an alchemy GS, so I wouldn’t count that as impressive. I didn’t say beat (since the context of the story was to save Merc) but overpower him not one but twice, first time when saving Lucy by overpowering Merc physically with mass change and and that change in mass allowed her to tank Merc’s attacks which are full power. Wendy just gave them Hax advantage via DSM that only gives eversion advantage. I don’t know, given past feats, at best on on the level, however with knowledge and limits on Macro it doesn’t make Mira have any real advantage.
 

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
2,049
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
No I am not. I am making it sound like Macro would work on someone who is a regular human and weaker than the user, Mira.

Brandish shrunk Erza yet Erza is not weaker than her, In fact, Erza scales to Laxus who was equal to or above Brandish a year ago. Hax has always worked on people weaker than the victim or even equal. So bringing up Brandish shrinking Mira to mean Mira can't macro her makes no sense. Awareness has only been confirmed as a counter to hypnosis via Erza and Lucy, not memory alteration or macro curse.

Again prove that Brandish knows about macro and more importantly, knows that Mirajane has macro. All you have are assumptions.

Laxus was weakened when he fought Wahl by the bane particles then Wahl cleared it and Laxus also unlocked red lightning, a power up. Save it. Brandish is a regular spriggan so she scales to Ajeel who Laxus was going to hurt had August not saved him. Laxus was weakened by bane particles and Wahl was strong against electricity for the majority of their fight and was still managing with him until the ending.

Brandish did not beat a dragon God so you can't say Brandish scales above Mira who had a superior feat against a CB with Wendy's boost. Mirajane was boosted by Wendy just like Laxus and Erza were so what is your point? Is Brandish stronger than Laxus?

There is no evidence it is NOT numbers. There is no proof that the fodder Alvarez soldiers were themselves blocking Macro. You are making up scenarious about them preparing a defense to push your narrative. They are irrelevant in the first place since Daemon who effortlessly got affected by it is way above each of them.

What prepared? Mira used macro one time. It affected a lot and many others were not affected. When were they preparing? They move faster than the sound of her voice reaching their ears?

Again I am asking you to prove Brandish would block macro. Prove Brandish is above Mira in power and prove Macro fails on weaker people. Also prove Brandish knows Mira has macro and prove her and the Alvalrez soldiers can block macro.

You're acting like Brandish could solo a CB lol. The CBs are stronger than Erza and Laxus at their best with Wendy's power up stacked on them. Brandish is just a regular spriggan the likes of Ajeel. She would scale to God Serena and we saw that Laxus is above this level currently. Mira scales to current Laxus and Erza via feats and hype.

LOL

" however with knowledge and limits on Macro it doesn’t make Mira have any real advantage. "

Literally stuff you are assuming though... ^^^^

Where is the proof that being aware of macro makes you immune?
Where is the proof that macro was resisted and blocked by the alvarez grunts and it wasn't just a limit in the number of persons she used it on at once?
Where is the proof that Brandish can resist macro?
Where is the proof that Brandish scales above Mirajane?
Where is the proof that macro is affected by power levels?
 
Last edited:

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,034
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
The thing about that is you have to compare it to say Seliah and Erza who is stronger than the former. Erza is weaker as stated Brandish’s magic does not work on those who are weaker than her, sure it may have worked on August but that would be due to him allowing her to affect him. Not without explicit rules in place that makes it a matter of power level difference Between opponents. No, the same for any other wizards like Gray, Lily, etc. via memory manipulation. The proof is by association, if multiple people in the same organization knew about Zeref and his history then there is no reason to assume Brandish doesn’t know about his past too seeing as she appeared to be aware of Natsu too Upon first encounter. That was only when the particles started to affect him after Wall transformed, Wall said he was still top tier FT wizard in-spite of having them inside him. yes a power up after all the damage Laxus received it made the red lightning incredibly strong. Maybe hurt but unclear if put down, considering Ajeel could match Erza who was compared to Laxus Prior, Laxus in his own words only weakened when they actually affect him. I did not say beat (not without circumstances) but overpowered him multiple times Through Lucy who is far weaker. Wendy’s boost is for range, that was it, she just gave them DS enchantment that hurts like kryptonite to Superman, and Laxus is a special case since he was partly dead, and beings who died can come back when they have magic put into them, DGs, Brain/Zero, etc especially when Laxus prior had his life/magic drained from him. and Wendy said that Laxus aside from the others when she intended to give DS magic to others. No, that there was no power up, just given DS enchantment, their power was theirs from the beginning and they still struggled, but Brandish overpowered a DG with her power. The fact that Lisanna said it did not work on some of them and that Mirajane did not pass out from power loss from using it on everyone. Because Macro has mental affects too and mental powers effectiveness relies on awareness. Daemon does not know about Macro so how would she know to defend against it? When they were not busy fighting FT members at the time. They can hit Natsu who can outrun lightning and even dodge light so yeah, they can react to it. Brandish being aware of the existence of Macro as she knows Zeref and his history by association is evident enough. Mira struggles against a CB while Brandish power can overwhelm a DG and even cause it damage. Macro shows mental affects like with Elfman as he become hypnotized after he is compelled to destroy FT. Again, Brandish knows Zeref’s past so she would know about Macro to counter. She pretty much could at this point with how disappointing they have been LOL. Hiro continues to add them and comments on their relevancy since Alvarez instead of having Diabolos aid them, instead they only got DS enchantment with no extra Boost as the effort for that form Wendy has is for range. and Brandish to around Full Power DG, that is relatively more powerful than Laxus and Erza had to fight currently on their own. Eflman as he was not hypnotized before being forced to destroy FT, the fact that Lisanna said that it didn’t work on some of them and Mira wasn’t completely drained by the effort of numbers. The fact Wall can resist it too since he was among the group. Brandish can overpower a DG and Mira could not, did not say power levels, just those who are aware of it, how Their bodies reacted is another matter, otherwise Mira would just command the DGs or Acno to just kill themselves Via NLF
 
Last edited:

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
2,049
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
The thing about that is you have to compare it to say Seliah and Erza who is stronger than the former. Erza is weaker as stated Brandish’s magic does not work on those who are weaker than her, sure it may have worked on August but that would be due to him allowing her to affect him. Not without explicit rules in place that makes it a matter of power level difference Between opponents. No, the same for any other wizards like Gray, Lily, etc. via memory manipulation.
The proof is by association, if multiple people in the same organization knew about Zeref and his history then there is no reason to assume Brandish doesn’t know about his past too seeing as she appeared to be aware of Natsu too Upon first encounter. That was only when the particles started to affect him after Wall transformed, Wall said he was still top tier FT wizard in-spite of having them inside him. yes a power up after all the damage Laxus received it made the red lightning incredibly strong. Maybe hurt but unclear if put down, considering Ajeel could match Erza who was compared to Laxus Prior, Laxus in his own words only weakened when they actually affect him.
That is not proof and you know it. How does Brandish know about macro and that Mira has it? Did Zeref tell his spriggan off panel that Mira had it? Wahl only found out she had it when he saw her use it so using Wahl is actually disproving Brandish having full intel on Mira and her macro.

Neinhart actively had Irene's enchantment swirling around him when Brandish's power failed and she was amazed on how much power he got from Irene. Erza and August were not doing anything. So it is erroneous to use Brandish vs Neinhart to say Mira is weaker than Brandish.

You are missing the forest for the trees and instead of accurately noting where FT's S class and Jellal stand you are trying a round about logic to prove Brandish > Erza and Laxus (forget Mirajane).

Laxus was portrayed on their level or above period. His interaction with Ajeel was enough. Him beating a spriggan unassisted unlike Erza is proof enough. The portrayal was clear.



I did not say beat (not without circumstances) but overpowered him multiple times Through Lucy who is far weaker. Wendy’s boost is for range, that was it, she just gave them DS enchantment that hurts like kryptonite to Superman, and Laxus is a special case since he was partly dead, and beings who died can come back when they have magic put into them, DGs, Brain/Zero, etc. and Wendy said that Laxus aside from the others when she intended to give DS magic to others. No, that there was no power up, just given DS enchantment, their power was theirs from the beginning and they still struggled, but Brandish overpowered a DG with her power.
Nope. It boosted them AND gave a DS enchantment. This is why Lucy said she got more powerful and Laxus said power was surging in him and he noticed it after his performance against Levia. Mira and Laxus also both noted Wendy's power up. Had it been dragon slaying enchantment only, nothing would've happened to Laxus at all.








The fact that Lisanna said it did not work on some of them and that Mirajane did not pass out from power loss from using it on everyone. Because Macro has mental affects too and mental powers effectiveness relies on awareness. Daemon does not know about Macro so how would she know to defend against it? When they were not busy fighting FT members at the time. They can hit Natsu who can outrun lightning and even light so yeah, they can react to it.
Macro is not hypnosis magic so using the limits established for hypnosis/illusion magic has no canon backing. It's a headcanon at present. It's a curse that gives control.

Lisanna saying it didn't work on some is not proof of them actively blocking it or being too strong to be affected. It's never confirmed. It's not even implied since you can mental gymnastics all you want, the unaffected ones were not shown preparing nor were they noted to be on another level from their peers.
Mira only being able to control X amount of people at once also was not disproven.

Not they cannot react to macro before it hits. How would they? There is no blast of lightning. They heard her the same time their friends did. Like??? How is even a thing? They defended against macro off panel and Mashima didn't have any character point it out or show them doing it? What proof is their that they blocked macro or actively reacted to it?


Brandish being aware of the existence of Macro as she knows Zeref and his history by association is evident enough. Mira struggles against a CB while Brandish power can overwhelm a DG and even cause it damage. Macro shows mental affects like with Elfman as he become hypnotized after he is compelled to destroy FT. Again, Brandish knows Zeref’s past so she would know about Macro to counter.
No it isn't. Wahl didn't know Mira had it until he saw it. You don't even have evidence of her knowing what macro even is. Saying Bloodman has macro so Brandish knows about it is still not proven. You don't even know if the spriggan know everything about one another.

Where are you getting the evidence that Brandish knows how to counter macro? You are literally making up stuff. Nothing from the manga.


She pretty much could at this point with how disappointing they have been LOL. Hiro continues to add them and comments on their relevancy since Alvarez instead of having Diabolos aid them, instead they only got DS enchantment with no extra Boost as the effort for that form Wendy has is for range. and Brandish to around Full Power DG, that is relatively more powerful than Laxus and Erza had to fight currently on their own. Eflman as he was not hypnotized before being forced to destroy FT, the fact that Lisanna said that it didn’t work on some of them and Mira wasn’t completely drained by the effort of numbers. The fact Wall can resist it too since he was among the group. Brandish can overpower a DG and Mira could not, did not say power levels, just those who are aware of it, how Their bodies reacted is another matter, otherwise Mira would just command the DGs or Acno to just kill themselves Via NLF

Yeah no.

You know who else Mashima comments about? Erza and Laxus. lol talking about the relevance of a spriggan who is not August/Irene but ignoring Mashima having Laxus beat Gildarts hyped opponents and talking about Laxus and Erza being the top members with Gildarts is strange.

Brandish being stronger than Laxus has no canon backing. God Serena is on her level or stronger and we saw how Jellal beat him arcs ago.

Brandish did not beat any DG. She didn't even toss him like Mira tossed Scissor Runner and smashed him into Levia. Your Brandish overhyping is strange.

Wahl resisting would fall into a numbers issue OR his weakness power defending against it in an unknown way so...

Which DG Mira fought? Wendy and Gray could hurt DGs like Brandish did. Mira, Laxus and Erza scale above them.
DGs are not proven heavier than CBs so Mira could toss a CB the same way.

Mashima not giving us a limit to macro fails and macro being able to low diff Acnologia are two different things and you know that.
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,034
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
That is not proof and you know it. How does Brandish know about macro and that Mira has it? Did Zeref tell his spriggan off panel that Mira had it? Wahl only found out she had it when he saw her use it so using Wahl is actually disproving Brandish having full intel on Mira and her macro.

Neinhart actively had Irene's enchantment swirling around him when Brandish's power failed and she was amazed on how much power he got from Irene. Erza and August were not doing anything. So it is erroneous to use Brandish vs Neinhart to say Mira is weaker than Brandish.

You are missing the forest for the trees and instead of accurately noting where FT's S class and Jellal stand you are trying a round about logic to prove Brandish > Erza and Laxus (forget Mirajane).

Laxus was portrayed on their level or above period. His interaction with Ajeel was enough. Him beating a spriggan unassisted unlike Erza is proof enough. The portrayal was clear.





Nope. It boosted them AND gave a DS enchantment.
This is why Lucy said she got more powerful and Laxus said power was surging in him and he noticed it after his performance against Levia. Mira and Laxus also both noted Wendy's power up. Had it been dragon slaying enchantment only, nothing would've happened to Laxus at all.








Macro is not hypnosis magic so using the limits established for hypnosis/illusion magic has no canon backing. It's a headcanon at present. It's a curse that gives control.

Lisanna saying it didn't work on some is not proof of them actively blocking it or being too strong to be affected. It's never confirmed. It's not even implied since you can mental gymnastics all you want, the unaffected ones were not shown preparing nor were they noted to be on another level from their peers.
Mira only being able to control X amount of people at once also was not disproven.

Not they cannot react to macro before it hits. How would they? There is no blast of lightning. They heard her the same time their friends did. Like??? How is even a thing? They defended against macro off panel and Mashima didn't have any character point it out or show them doing it? What proof is their that they blocked macro or actively reacted to it?




No it isn't. Wahl didn't know Mira had it until he saw it. You don't even have evidence of her knowing what macro even is. Saying Bloodman has macro so Brandish knows about it is still not proven. You don't even know if the spriggan know everything about one another.

Where are you getting the evidence that Brandish knows how to counter macro? You are literally making up stuff. Nothing from the manga.



Yeah no.

You know who else Mashima comments about? Erza and Laxus. lol talking about the relevance of a spriggan who is not August/Irene but ignoring Mashima having Laxus beat Gildarts hyped opponents and talking about Laxus and Erza being the top members with Gildarts is strange.

Brandish being stronger than Laxus has no canon backing. God Serena is on her level or stronger and we saw how Jellal beat him arcs ago.

Brandish did not beat any DG. She didn't even toss him like Mira tossed Scissor Runner and smashed him into Levia. Your Brandish overhyping is strange.

Wahl resisting would fall into a numbers issue OR his weakness power defending against it in an unknown way so...

Which DG Mira fought? Wendy and Gray could hurt DGs like Brandish did. Mira, Laxus and Erza scale above them.
DGs are not proven heavier than CBs so Mira could toss a CB the same way.

Mashima not giving us a limit to macro fails and macro being able to low diff Acnologia are two different things and you know that.
Considering that Zeref made Seliah which had Macro and the Spriggans are aware of his playthings, apparently as Wall knew about it without being surprised or questioning it. And Zeref said he gets as much information on his enemies as he can, and he was there during the Tartaros arc. Yes but that didn’t mean his body could contain it, he just had overflowing MP Where stats equal MP. against August would allow it to affect him, I doubt Erza would too, same with Natsu who was ready to fight Brandish and she affected him. Jellal was oneshotted by Neinhart when he did not even use his strongest spell against a doll GS defeating him so I am not sure where you are getting with that. Laxus may be able to put up a fight against Ajeel, but still a “maybe” considering he struggled to put down Wall who could tank his physical attacks that scales to his own MP, and Wall is the weakest, Laxus needed a powerup to win along with a new spell, so he had indirect assist. I will give you that for the power up, but considering Aldoron was massively weakened at the time, it is not that significant, even CB could not oneshot a weakened DG. Even if it was just DS enchantment, it would work like kryptonite, painful to drains as shown with motherglare. not hypnosis, but mind powers which is limited by awareness which is common in FT, Elfman was clearly hypnotized at the time he blew up FT Since he wants to destroy it. so does mind control powers which is control over the mind. Nor is it confirmed that numbers were affected Since Mirajane was not drained of power after that use against all of them, that is pretty much given for any spell that requires energy to use, that was because for dramatic affect it shows only the ones affected only to reveal later that there are those who were not affected. It has since she did not revert back to normal as she would be out of power. They can, their blasts scales to the speed or lightning/light since they hit Natsu. Those ones affected were the ones busy fighting So they had no time to prepare. Lisanna pointed it out that they were not affected. The fact that Mira retains her Seliah form without wasting all her magic on supposedly “x” number of people and the fact Wall did not change forms or made weakness soldiers from it. Wall did know as he was not shocked nor questioned it, and Zeref was there at Tartaros so he would know what happened and stated to collect information on enemies. How so? The fact that he lacked any significant magic at all yet scales to the other Spriggan would be evident enough were someone like Gajeel would catch on. Considering that Gildarts power who he can’t control wasn’t a risk to Aldoron and yet a weakened Zeref was would give the impression that Gildarts is rather stagnant in his growth and Hiro did state that he refuses to utilize power creep to keep the settings as they are. Yet you are the only using different stat characters to beat one another, Brandish could stab August with no issue, so in retrospect, Ajeel would be fine without August’s help if the latter was not that strong in that case. I try to look at what is given As a whole, not in small sections. Not so because again Mirajane would return to her original form if it was a numbers issue with loss of power. Laxus has issues with CB even with power up, and Brandish with her power can damage a full power Dragon God. That was a doll which is weaker than Neinhart which managed to survive and escape from a full power Jellel that split the skies and brought stars down on him, where as doll GS died to a standard Grand Chariot with two extra attacks. Massive difference in performance. Through Lucy she did as she even managed to overpower the biting strength of Merc with her magic, again, I didn’t say defeat given the circumstances, but damages as wither power, Merc shed blood. Scissor runner is massively weaker than a full power DG As they could not put down one weakened One. Mira fought no DG, that just makes Wendy on that level through her own power, where as Gray with the DSM enchantment used strategy to hamper one of them To allow victory as conditions can affect stats. Says the giant sea snake and tree dragon compared to CB dragons. They are the same as that is NLF which we must conclude why Mira hadn’t used that curse if it was OP, Dragons wouldn’t be able to resist it anyway since it’s not magic.
 
Last edited:

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,283
Reaction score
2,049
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
Considering that Zeref made Seliah which had Macro and the Spriggans are aware of his playthings, apparently as Wall knew about it without being surprised or questioning it. And Zeref said he gets as much information on his enemies as he can, and he was there during the Tartaros arc. Yes but that didn’t mean his body could contain it, he just had overflowing MP Where stats equal MP. against August would allow it to affect him, I doubt Erza would too, same with Natsu who was ready to fight Brandish and she affected him.
One spriggan was aware of Tartaros demons curses. That does not mean all of them do. He did not know Mirajane had macro until after she used it so why would Brandish know Mira has macro.

Brandish has no feats or hype of resisting macro or curses from anyone let alone current Mirajane who scales above her.


Jellal was oneshotted by Neinhart when he did not even use his strongest spell against a doll GS defeating him so I am not sure where you are getting with that. Laxus may be able to put up a fight against Ajeel, but still a “maybe” considering he struggled to put down Wall who could tank his physical attacks that scales to his own MP, and Wall is the weakest, Laxus needed a powerup to win along with a new spell, so he had indirect assist.
You are being disingenuous. Jellal got hurt saving Kagura and he beat Neinhart without using his strongest spell either.




And you surely know what I am getting at i.e. God Serena is equal to or above Brandish and Jellal scales above him so Laxus who is compared to Jellal and Erza scales above her clearly.


Mashima:
 August= Irene > Larcade, DiMaria, God Serena ~ Last place is Wahl.


Laxus was facing an opponent that was immune to his magic. He also had his illness act up in the fight. You're ignoring context to diminish characters. LOL.
Ajeel who was not immune to Laxus's lightning was in danger as per August himself.


I will give you that for the power up, but considering Aldoron was massively weakened at the time, it is not that significant, even CB could not oneshot a weakened DG. Even if it was just DS enchantment, it would work like kryptonite, painful to drains as shown with motherglare. not hypnosis, but mind powers which is limited by awareness which is common in FT, Elfman was clearly hypnotized at the time he blew up FT Since he wants to destroy it. so does mind control powers which is control over the mind.
Macro is not hypnosis and it's not magic. You are constantly treating identically to hypnosis magic when it's not and touting this as a fact. It's your assumption at best.


Nor is it confirmed that numbers were affected Since Mirajane was not drained of power after that use against all of them, that is pretty much given for any spell that requires energy to use, that was because for dramatic affect it shows only the ones affected only to reveal later that there are those who were not affected. It has since she did not revert back to normal as she would be out of power. They can, their blasts scales to the speed or lightning/light since they hit Natsu. Those ones affected were the ones busy fighting So they had no time to prepare. Lisanna pointed it out that they were not affected. The fact that Mira retains her Seliah form without wasting all her magic on supposedly “x” number of people and the fact Wall did not change forms or made weakness soldiers from it.
I never said it was confirmed. I said it was a logical conclusion, which it is. You're the one claiming it's a fact that the Alvarez fodder saw it coming and defended against it and are somehow using that to say current Mira would fail to control current Brandish as a result. Lisanna said it didn't work on some of them no one said why it didn't work so you are speculating.

Your speculation also makes less sense than mine since yours includes soldiers reacting to the speed of sound of mira's voice before her curse affects them like their comrades and/or random Alvarez fodder being to strong for Mira's macro while a bunch of them easily fell.

Wall did know as he was not shocked nor questioned it, and Zeref was there at Tartaros so he would know what happened and stated to collect information on enemies. How so? The fact that he lacked any significant magic at all yet scales to the other Spriggan would be evident enough were someone like Gajeel would catch on. Considering that Gildarts power who he can’t control wasn’t a risk to Aldoron and yet a weakened Zeref was would give the impression that Gildarts is rather stagnant in his growth and Hiro did state that he refuses to utilize power creep to keep the settings as they are. Yet you are the only using different stat characters to beat one another, Brandish could stab August with no issue, so in retrospect, Ajeel would be fine without August’s help if the latter was not that strong in that case.
Again prove that Brandish and every single spriggan knows about all the Tartaros curses and that Mirajane has them. Wahl is notably well informed. He knew Zeref and Mavis were lovers, he knew about Tartaros and macro and he knew what was Ajeel's strongest move. Automatically assuming that Brandish knows everything a notably smart and informed characters does is not evidence that she does.

Mashima states he tries to keep the guild power balance the same. This has nothing to do with the spriggan or outside characters. Nice try. So Erza and Laxus would always be in the top tier of FT and relative to one another however this doesn't mean that the regular spriggan would grow to match or beat them.

August said he was in trouble. Jellal beat Neinhart without his strongest move. Why would we assume Ajeel would've been fine vs someone of Laxus' power?


I try to look at what is given As a whole, not in small sections. Not so because again Mirajane would return to her original form if it was a numbers issue with loss of power. Laxus has issues with CB even with power up, and Brandish with her power can damage a full power Dragon God.
Disingenuous again. Lucy with Brandish's boost admitted she was not match for Merc THEN she hurt him when she used her Taurus start dress in her giant form. It was not Brandish's magic only that allowed her to slam him.



That was a doll which is weaker than Neinhart which managed to survive and escape from a full power Jellel that split the skies and brought stars down on him, where as doll GS died to a standard Grand Chariot with two extra attacks. Massive difference in performance.
Nothing confirms God Serena was weaker when he was revived. This was not corpse historia. Gray even said he was still the strongest mage in Ishgar. His magic couldn't be used as a dead man for Athena. That's all what was said outside of the signarios sisters mocking him.

Through Lucy she did as she even managed to overpower the biting strength of Merc with her magic, again, I didn’t say defeat given the circumstances, but damages as wither power, Merc shed blood. Scissor runner is massively weaker than a full power DG As they could not put down one weakened One. Mira fought no DG, that just makes Wendy on that level through her own power, where as Gray with the DSM enchantment used strategy to hamper one of them To allow victory as conditions can affect stats. Says the giant sea snake and tree dragon compared to CB dragons. They are the same as that is NLF which we must conclude why Mira hadn’t used that curse if it was OP, Dragons wouldn’t be able to resist it anyway since it’s not magic.
Lucy combined her Taurus form with Brandish's gigantification to slam him.

Mirajane with wendy's enchantment threw Scissor runner from a great distance, he spun uncontrollably and slammed into Levia thus hurting both dragons and shocking them. Scissor runner being weaker says nothing about his weight and Mira showed no signs ot fatigue throwing him. So no Brandish magic on it's own did nothing compared to Laxus matching Levia's roar or Mira ragdolling a multi ton dragon.

You can't get out of this. lol Are Gray and Wendy above Laxus because of their Dragon God feats or not? Because you are saying Brandish > Laxus and Mira for what Lucy did with her help.
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,034
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
One spriggan was aware of Tartaros demons curses. That does not mean all of them do. He did not know Mirajane had macro until after she used it so why would Brandish know Mira has macro.

Brandish has no feats or hype of resisting macro or curses from anyone let alone current Mirajane who scales above her.




You are being disingenuous. Jellal got hurt saving Kagura and he beat Neinhart without using his strongest spell either.




And you surely know what I am getting at i.e. God Serena is equal to or above Brandish and Jellal scales above him so Laxus who is compared to Jellal and Erza scales above her clearly.


Mashima:
 August= Irene > Larcade, DiMaria, God Serena ~ Last place is Wahl.


Laxus was facing an opponent that was immune to his magic. He also had his illness act up in the fight. You're ignoring context to diminish characters. LOL.
Ajeel who was not immune to Laxus's lightning was in danger as per August himself.




Macro is not hypnosis and it's not magic. You are constantly treating identically to hypnosis magic when it's not and touting this as a fact. It's your assumption at best.




I never said it was confirmed. I said it was a logical conclusion, which it is. You're the one claiming it's a fact that the Alvarez fodder saw it coming and defended against it and are somehow using that to say current Mira would fail to control current Brandish as a result. Lisanna said it didn't work on some of them no one said why it didn't work so you are speculating.

Your speculation also makes less sense than mine since yours includes soldiers reacting to the speed of sound of mira's voice before her curse affects them like their comrades and/or random Alvarez fodder being to strong for Mira's macro while a bunch of them easily fell.


Again prove that Brandish and every single spriggan knows about all the Tartaros curses and that Mirajane has them. Wahl is notably well informed. He knew Zeref and Mavis were lovers, he knew about Tartaros and macro and he knew what was Ajeel's strongest move. Automatically assuming that Brandish knows everything a notably smart and informed characters does is not evidence that she does.

Mashima states he tries to keep the guild power balance the same. This has nothing to do with the spriggan or outside characters. Nice try. So Erza and Laxus would always be in the top tier of FT and relative to one another however this doesn't mean that the regular spriggan would grow to match or beat them.

August said he was in trouble. Jellal beat Neinhart without his strongest move. Why would we assume Ajeel would've been fine vs someone of Laxus' power?


Disingenuous again. Lucy with Brandish's boost admitted she was not match for Merc THEN she hurt him when she used her Taurus start dress in her giant form. It was not Brandish's magic only that allowed her to slam him.




Nothing confirms God Serena was weaker when he was revived. This was not corpse historia. Gray even said he was still the strongest mage in Ishgar. His magic couldn't be used as a dead man for Athena. That's all what was said outside of the signarios sisters mocking him.



Lucy combined her Taurus form with Brandish's gigantification to slam him.

Mirajane with wendy's enchantment threw Scissor runner from a great distance, he spun uncontrollably and slammed into Levia thus hurting both dragons and shocking them. Scissor runner being weaker says nothing about his weight and Mira showed no signs ot fatigue throwing him. So no Brandish magic on it's own did nothing compared to Laxus matching Levia's roar or Mira ragdolling a multi ton dragon.

You can't get out of this. lol Are Gray and Wendy above Laxus because of their Dragon God feats or not? Because you are saying Brandish > Laxus and Mira for what Lucy did with her help.
four actually, it does, Zeref had information on everyone at the time of Alvarez Arc. If Wall can resist it, then so could Brandish given the circumstances. Jellal got hurt from saving Natsu from Zero and he was weakened, injured prior and had no memories of his past life and yet was conscious still. That is far stronger than pretty much an other display of power Jellal performed as he parted the atmosphere itself. Jellal struggled against a weaker version of GS And used a non-serious Grand Chariot to pretty much kill it while Neinhart survived a bloodthirsty natural disaster level attack. Not resistant to his physical attacks that scales to his magic as MP = stats, illness did not affect him until it did as Laxus stated Earlier, you are you’re ignoring context to diminish characters yourself. Yet from your context of different stats facing one another, August was not necessary as Brandish could seriously injure the former. Alchamy is Not magic either yet has techniques that are still treated as hypnosis that can be countered by awareness, it is based on how techniques in general with mental affects are countered by awareness. Like how being dead makes it hard To you macro on as Seliah said. That is still not a logical conclusion as Mira retained her Seliah form in the end without running out of power as that is a fact. Which is a logical conclusion too as they were not busy fighting unlike those who were currently fighting. And considering Wall is among them makes sense as well, didn’t work is not the same as didn’t reach them. Since they can react to Natsu who can move faster than sound via reacting to lightning and light itself would make sense, again, those affected were the ones fighting while those were not had opportunity to prepare for it. Again, as she is a spriggan with a demon on her team who had all the demon curses and associated with Zeref, and Neinhart who looks deep into the hearts of others knows enough about Bloodman, as the lore of FT states, magic does not lie, He was not even shocked as well, so they would knew about their existence prior, and Wall said that with around half the other Spriggans here and they were not surprised themselves. And yet he continues to give them stats and scaling after Alvarez with having Brandish help out against the more important battle in FT’s lives And downgrade even someone like Gray, since Brandish a spriggan didn’t grow and yet can matcha DG would show otherwise. I don’t recall August saying he was in trouble when he was being stabbed, if you meant Ajeel all he said would be sad to lose a comrade, that doesn’t mean anything beyond a simple guess. sure but is titanically stronger than his average Grand Chariot he beat doll GS with. Since Wall could take Laxus’ power at the time since stats = MP. Considering that Brandish did not state that was Lucy’s max size so she couldn’t use her power points to that not being Brandish’s best, and Aquarius is stronger than Taurus form based on official stat Cards from FT volumes, the only reason she didn’t use it because of Merc’s water affinity that actually made him stronger than before. His defeat against an average Grand Chariot makes him a weaker version of GS as a stronger version could not kill Neinhart and managed to escape. As magic of the dead is insufficient Said Duke, not incompatable. Which Taurus is weaker than Aquarius in every stat. Scissors was smaller than Merc and weaker too, it does when Merc is larger and thus heavier, Not showing fatigue to a CB is one thing, against a DG is another as a weakened one could hold their own against a CB. Brandish magic overpowered the biting strength of a DB which is more impressive than throwing a CB. Gray with strategy yes, power no, Wendy at full potential yes as she could break the stones of a weaker Dragon God too. In fact Wendy was likely above Laxus back in Tartaros as she could break a Face when Jura who gave High End fight to Laxus couldn’t.
 
Top