Conditional Mirajane vs Brandish

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,277
Reaction score
2,044
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
Gray confirmed they have more training and stronger magic so that would be a factor. It could be that those affected were caught off guard or what not, that does have a factor in a fight against stronger enemies too like August, Brandish, Jose, etc.. Mira said that she commanded everyone, so all the grunts present would be affected. Macro does not work on Demons before 100YQ, so Mira would be strong enough to affect them now. It did not work on Laxus before because of his different mindset under the influence of the White Wizard. Brandish and Daemon are roughly around the same level given how their powers can affect Dragon Gods. Given how Macro is used a lot when enemies are off guard, that would explain it’s affectiveness. Which would add to why that will not work in this fight since Brandish knows about it via Zeref.
Gray said they were stronger than Avatar grunts. Nothing about Erza, Elfman, Minerva from a year back and nothing about them being stronger than the ones Mira commanded since he's actually refering to the ones Mira commanded since he said this before Mirajane used macro.

Mira said I command you all to sleep and then said I guess these are the ones they'll have to beat up. Nothing implies or states that the grunts in the back were stronger than the ones in front and resisted her by training or actively defending. We just know it did not work. Saying 1 faceless grunt is stronger than the others isn't really shown. A limit on the numbers is still a viable reason.

Laxus can be affected by Kyria
Erza can be affected by Brandish,
Brandish can be affected by Mest.
Why would Mira fail to control Brandish?

This is current Mira, Brandish and Daemon in 100 years quest I'm talking about so again bringing up Alvarez grunts fail to prove anything,

Nothing in canon indicates being aware of macro blocks it. It's not hypnosis. It's a curse that controls them against their will. You are making up a condition. Macro has never been stated to or implied to be effective because you catch someone off guard.

Logically because macro has no canon counter with power level being great or being aware AND Mira scales to current Laxus, we have little reason to believe Brandish is immune. Mest's memory alteration worked on her.
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,030
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Gray said they were stronger than Avatar grunts. Nothing about Erza, Elfman, Minerva from a year back and nothing about them being stronger than the ones Mira commanded since he's actually refering to the ones Mira commanded since he said this before Mirajane used macro.

Mira said I command you all to sleep and then said I guess these are the ones they'll have to beat up. Nothing implies or states that the grunts in the back were stronger than the ones in front and resisted her by training or actively defending. We just know it did not work. Saying 1 faceless grunt is stronger than the others isn't really shown. A limit on the numbers is still a viable reason.

Laxus can be affected by Kyria
Erza can be affected by Brandish,
Brandish can be affected by Mest.
Why would Mira fail to control Brandish?

This is current Mira, Brandish and Daemon in 100 years quest I'm talking about so again bringing up Alvarez grunts fail to prove anything,

Nothing in canon indicates being aware of macro blocks it. It's not hypnosis. It's a curse that controls them against their will. You are making up a condition. Macro has never been stated to or implied to be effective because you catch someone off guard.

Logically because macro has no canon counter with power level being great or being aware AND Mira scales to current Laxus, we have little reason to believe Brandish is immune. Mest's memory alteration worked on her.
That doesn’t change the fact they are strong, that they could easily damage someone like Natsu, that doesn’t imply it related to numbers as well since she said “everyone”, it would be all her enemies in the range of her FOE, and she can cover hundreds of meters. It is common strategy to send in fodder first to weaken your enemies with better via Wall, again, it would be a matter of being aware of the ability happening to take effect, mental fortitude is a factor in those kinds of powers afterall. Laxus did not get affected by Kyria since he had a different mindset prior. Brandish had equal or greater magic Than Erza. Brandish was not aware as Memory magic as Mest used stealth like illusion or mind powers like that are weak to awareness. It is still relevant as it comes down to if they are aware or not of Macro affecting them, those grunts who were affected were likely not paying attention to her at the time and the others did resisted, Mira did not become fatigue from the numbers affected either as it does drain power like how Mira gained Macro from Seliah drained her stamina. It is not about power level, it is about mental strength and being aware of it. Again, Mest worked on Brandish because she was not paying attention to him and it is stated memory fails with awareness.
 

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,277
Reaction score
2,044
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
That doesn’t change the fact they are strong, that they could easily damage someone like Natsu, that doesn’t imply it related to numbers as well since she said “everyone”, it would be all her enemies in the range of her FOE, and she can cover hundreds of meters. It is common strategy to send in fodder first to weaken your enemies with better via Wall, again, it would be a matter of being aware of the ability happening to take effect, mental fortitude is a factor in those kinds of powers afterall. Laxus did not get affected by Kyria since he had a different mindset prior. Brandish had equal or greater magic Than Erza. Brandish was not aware as Memory magic as Mest used stealth like illusion or mind powers like that are weak to awareness. It is still relevant as it comes down to if they are aware or not of Macro affecting them, those grunts who were affected were likely not paying attention to her at the time and the others did resisted, Mira did not become fatigue from the numbers affected either as it does drain power like how Mira gained Macro from Seliah drained her stamina. It is not about power level, it is about mental strength and being aware of it. Again, Mest worked on Brandish because she was not paying attention to him and it is stated memory fails with awareness.

Mental fortitude was not shown to be a factor for Macro and even if it was random soldier fodder having that ability when Erza and Elfman a year before didn't have it and Daemon a year after also lacked it makes 0 sense. Mashima has still not shown a confirmed counter for macro. Funny enough he makes Mira just not use it instead of having it fail. You also do not know if Brandish is one of those who can even break out of it if that is the case. We also do not know if the alvarez soldiers defended against it or Mira could've only used it on some of them simultaneously.

Laxus got affected by Kyria the 2nd time because there was no white witch and barely managed to break out because Lucy was going to die. Nothing of that sort happened to those random soldiers. Even if awareness helps against hypnosis which is what Erza told us, macro is not hypnotic magic. It is a curse that controls.

Mira literaly absorbed Seilah's power via takeover which is how there was a drain in power.

Your assumption that Brandish would just break out of macro because she is allegedly aware of it and because some Alvarez fodder of dozens weren't affected at the same time, lacks canon backing.

Mirajane is also the strongest version of herself now hence her macro working on Daemon and her Alegria and Thorn curse keeping up with Elexion Soul powered Laxus so the assumption that her curses like macro would fail on Brandish who is likely weaker than her makes little sense.

It's also using a lot of assumptions i.e. Brandish can break out due to mental power; Brandish knows about macro; Alvarez soldiers defended themselves somehow while the others fell; Brandish can instantly avoid macro without struggle before Mira ends her.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

- Mira is on par with current Laxus
-Brandish was on par with or weaker than Laxus a year ago (unlikely she powered up beyond him now)
-Macro worked easily on Daemon a few chapters ago
-Brandish has no feat or hype of countering macro
-Macro is not hypnosis so has no canon proof of awareness weakening it
-Nothing proved Alvarez fodder focussed and blocked macro while dozens of their friends fell for it at the same time
-Alvarez grunts has no prep time to focus since she used it on the whole crowd
-Macro worked on Tartaros Erza in Tartaros, Daemon in 100 years quest and numerous Alvarez lackies in Alvarez.
-Mira's Alegria curses are still relevant and thorn curse is on par with Elexion Soul Laxus' lightning.
-Brandish's hax worked on Mira and Erza in 100 years quest and she's their equal or inferior power wise.

Nothing here indicates Brandish is immune to macro but Mira would get one shot by her powers.
 
Last edited:

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,030
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Mental fortitude was not shown to be a factor for Macro and even if it was random soldier fodder having that ability when Erza and Elfman a year before didn't have it and Daemon a year after also lacked it makes 0 sense. Mashima has still not shown a confirmed counter for macro. Funny enough he makes Mira just not use it instead of having it fail. You also do not know if Brandish is one of those who can even break out of it if that is the case. We also do not know if the alvarez soldiers defended against it or Mira could've only used it on some of them simultaneously.

Laxus got affected by Kyria the 2nd time because there was no white witch and barely managed to break out because Lucy was going to die. Nothing of that sort happened to those random soldiers. Even if awareness helps against hypnosis which is what Erza told us, macro is not hypnotic magic. It is a curse that controls.

Mira literaly absorbed Seilah's power via takeover which is how there was a drain in power.

Your assumption that Brandish would just break out of macro because she is allegedly aware of it and because some Alvarez fodder of dozens weren't affected at the same time, lacks canon backing.

Mirajane is also the strongest version of herself now hence her macro working on Daemon and her Alegria and Thorn curse keeping up with Elexion Soul powered Laxus so the assumption that her curses like macro would fail on Brandish who is likely weaker than her makes little sense.

It's also using a lot of assumptions i.e. Brandish can break out due to mental power; Brandish knows about macro; Alvarez soldiers defended themselves somehow while the others fell; Brandish can instantly avoid macro without struggle before Mira ends her.
Given that Elfman retained his mental state trying to resist prior to blowing up FT and his eyes were normal, after he decided he was going to his eyes changed, that would be the factor of mental fortitude. Again, they didn’t know about that power so they would likely not be ready for it, which any mental based power is hard to counter if they are not aware of it. Considering it is likely a non-factor going forward, and Seliah form should not exist since Zeref was dead and all his demons should be dead too, 100YQ is known for it’s retcons Afterall. Considering Wall was there and fully aware of the existence of Macro via Zeref, no reason Brandish wouldn’t know either. Considering they were in the middle of battle with other FT members makes them more than likely not pay attention, considering her wording includes all of them so it is not a one at a time thing. It was still a different mind set as stated that WW magic makes them personally different than before, and cutting works like illusion, weak to awareness. Those would be ones that likely paid attention to her And not on the other wizards, it can still be resisted as Elfman showed us which via visuals. That power was Macro which requires energy, which would be evident if it was a number issue then Mira would be drained of power by then, just like with the issue with numbers via Fairy Law. Brandish works under Zeref, she knows his history, Wall demonstrated to be aware of it too, again those soldiers would be distracted fighting other FT members. sure it MIGHT work now given her battle with Daemon but not absolutely as Brandish‘s power was strong enough to harm a DG, again, those soldiers were busy fighting while the others likely paid attention to her. Laxus struggled to put down base Wall who was the weakest Spriggan (And Laxus’ strength is equal to his MP) before his sickness hampered him. Elfman was mentally controlled by Macro so it does have mental powers. Those other soldiers were busy fighting to not pay attention, Wall was not affected either. Mira was not drained of power by numbers. Those who weren’t in front would have prep time since they were not fighting yet. Erza who was distracted. Daemon did not know about Macro and those Alvarez grunts were busy fighting. Not that impressive against an enemy weaker than a full powered DG, considering her power level can harm a DG, I doubt that at this point. Given that it showed resistance is a factor via eyes and that Mira did not get tired out via numbers she affected, Macro can be resisted and Brandish would be no exception.
 

AmitDS

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
1,277
Reaction score
2,044
Age
33
Country
Trinidad and Tobago
Given that Elfman retained his mental state trying to resist prior to blowing up FT and his eyes were normal, after he decided he was going to his eyes changed, that would be the factor of mental fortitude. Again, they didn’t know about that power so they would likely not be ready for it, which any mental based power is hard to counter if they are not aware of it. Considering it is likely a non-factor going forward, and Seliah form should not exist since Zeref was dead and all his demons should be dead too, 100YQ is known for it’s retcons Afterall.
Again you have no character breaking out of it with mental fortitude. Elfman and Erza were not hypnotised and resisted but Seilah calmly stood back and they failed. Claiming Brandish would break out of it vs Current Mirajane has no backing especially when Mira is above any form of Seilah and likely above Brandish herself.

Does Brandish even know about Macro in the first place?

Seilah form not existing was never rooted in canon. It's again a headcanon being touted as a logical conclusion. Mirajane used takeover on Tartaros before Zeref died. That power was hers, she became one with them and made it her own. Nothing to do with Zeref.

It's a non factor but Mirajane used it successfully vs Daemon recently. Ok?

Considering Wall was there and fully aware of the existence of Macro via Zeref, no reason Brandish wouldn’t know either. Considering they were in the middle of battle with other FT members makes them more than likely not pay attention, considering her wording includes all of them so it is not a one at a time thing. It was still a different mind set as stated that WW magic makes them personally different than before, and cutting works like illusion, weak to awareness.
There you go again. This is all assumptions and headcanon. Wall who analyses weaknesses and is basically a computer knowing about macro doesn't mean Brandish would know.

Those would be ones that likely paid attention to her And not on the other wizards, it can still be resisted as Elfman showed us which via visuals. That power was Macro which requires energy, which would be evident if it was a number issue then Mira would be drained of power by then, just like with the issue with numbers via Fairy Law.
If the fodder were too strong for Macro it would have shocked Mira. Not have her smile at the fact that she gets to beat them up. It being a numbers issue makes perfect sense since they were ALL FODDER and it worked on a lot but not all. Same enemies. You're trying to headcanon strong Alvarez soldiers dressed, acting and fighting identically as weak soldiers and doing some OP defensive meditation to counter macro OFF PANEL.

Brandish works under Zeref, she knows his history, Wall demonstrated to be aware of it too, again those soldiers would be distracted fighting other FT members. sure it MIGHT work now given her battle with Daemon but not absolutely as Brandish‘s power was strong enough to harm a DG, again, those soldiers were busy fighting while the others likely paid attention to her. Laxus struggled to put down base Wall who was the weakest Spriggan (And Laxus’ strength is equal to his MP) before his sickness hampered him.
Brandish working under Zeref doesn't mean she knows every detail of his life; she knows about macro and she knows Mira has macro.
Daemon literally hurt a Dragon God too.

Elfman was mentally controlled by Macro so it does have mental powers. Those other soldiers were busy fighting to not pay attention, Wall was not affected either. Mira was not drained of power by numbers. Those who weren’t in front would have prep time since they were not fighting yet.
Elfman was going to kill Lisanna and that mental boost did nothing to stop him. Is there a greater bolster for 'mental fortitude' for a Strauss sibling?

Why would Mira have to be drained of power if she could theoretically only use macro on X number of people at once?

Prep time for what? You keep saying they resisted and prepared for macro. How could they when she spoke to all of them together? The speed the sound of her voice traveled from the front to the back and in that gap they started their counter? They moved faster than her voice traveled?

Erza who was distracted. Daemon did not know about Macro and those Alvarez grunts were busy fighting. Not that impressive against an enemy weaker than a full powered DG, considering her power level can harm a DG, I doubt that at this point. Given that it showed resistance is a factor via eyes and that Mira did not get tired out via numbers she affected, Macro can be resisted and Brandish would be no exception.
-Daemon hurt Aldoron and macro worked on her fine.
-There is no evidence distraction helps macro work.
-No evidence it's hypnosis that can be resisted by awareness.
Resistance factor via eyes? Lol they were not hypnotised, their body was controlled against their will. Clearly they would try to resist and show their stuggle shown in their eyes.
-You're using ONLY headcanons.

We have 0 evidence that Brandish, who is weaker than Mira can resist macro. Mira scales to current Laxus.
 
Last edited:

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
7,030
Reaction score
2,562
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Again you have no character breaking out of it with mental fortitude. Elfman and Erza were not hypnotised and resisted but Seilah calmly stood back and they failed. Claiming Brandish would break out of it vs Current Mirajane has no backing especially when Mira is above any form of Seilah and likely above Brandish herself.

Does Brandish even know about Macro in the first place?

Seilah form not existing was never rooted in canon. It's again a headcanon being touted as a logical conclusion. Mirajane used takeover on Tartaros before Zeref died. That power was hers, she became one with them and made it her own. Nothing to do with Zeref.

It's a non factor but Mirajane used it successfully vs Daemon recently. Ok?



There you go again. This is all assumptions and headcanon. Wall who analyses weaknesses and is basically a computer knowing about macro doesn't mean Brandish would know.



If the fodder were too strong for Macro it would have shocked Mira. Not have her smile at the fact that she gets to beat them up. It being a numbers issue makes perfect sense since they were ALL FODDER and it worked on a lot but not all. Same enemies. You're trying to headcanon strong Alvarez soldiers dressed, acting and fighting identically as weak soldiers and doing some OP defensive meditation to counter macro OFF PANEL.



Brandish working under Zeref doesn't mean she knows every detail of his life; she knows about macro and she knows Mira has macro.
Daemon literally hurt a Dragon God too.



Elfman was going to kill Lisanna and that mental boost did nothing to stop him. Is there a greater bolster for 'mental fortitude' for a Strauss sibling?


Why would Mira have to be drained of power if she could theoretically only use macro on X number of people at once?

Prep time for what? You keep saying they resisted and prepared for macro. How could they when she spoke to all of them together? The speed the sound of her voice traveled from the front to the back and in that gap they started their counter? They moved faster than her voice traveled?



-Daemon hurt Aldoron and macro worked on her fine.
-There is no evidence distraction helps macro work.
-No evidence it's hypnosis that can be resisted by awareness.
Resistance factor via eyes? Lol they were not hypnotised, their body was controlled against their will. Clearly they would try to resist and show their stuggle shown in their eyes.
-You're using ONLY headcanons.

We have 0 evidence that Brandish, who is weaker than Mira can resist macro. Mira scales to current Laxus.
That just shows Elfman and Erza at the time had weaker resistance than the Alvarez soldiers. all this makes it sound like NLF as it makes it sound like Macro can work on the likes of Acnologia or the Five Dragon Gods. I would say that Mira would have scaled to Brandish given her feat against Daemon, however after her struggle against A CB dragon, I am not so sure.Yes given she knows about Zeref’s history and demons that tried to kill him. and Tartaros is still a demon of Zeref which was stated when Zeref dies, anything related to him dies too. Similarly to Natsu not being entirely a demon as he is a human with a demon’s power. Wall never created a Weakness soldier from it nor did he showed visuals of him analyzing Macro which he changes his form for, he just stood back there knowing it was something related to Zeref calling them one of his play toys. Lisanna and Gray was surprised for the both of them, besides Mira is a sadist so she gets to enjoy beating them up, it is not like they couldn’t handle the situation, just more effort to put in. If it were numbers, she would have been drained of power instantly since it requires energy. Doesn’t make all Of them equal whether it be skills, power or circumstances, just like how being aware of a mind controlling power has limits with it. It was on panel, she included everyone so even those in the back would be affected. They know about Natsu being END, something even Tartaros did not even know. Iwill refer to Daemon part to my earlier quote above. It prevented him from killing his sister sooner, it is for anyone really that shows it, Erza, Elfman, MInerva, etc.. Since it uses her own power makes anyone fatigue as Seilah showed when she lost her power. Not all of them were fighting, meaning those who weren’t would be more than able to be prepared. Alvarez grunts were able to hurt Natsu and he can dodge lightning and that is hundreds to thousands of times faster than sound. Mental powers =/= MP, hence why Memory can work on even stronger characters who are not aware of it. Erza and gang were distracted trying to stop Face. None of those aware were mentally compelled other than Elfman who gave in later on, he was literally spouting for FT to die while under the influence via eyes. There is nothing suggesting Macro being all powerful either, that is NLF. Mira and Laxus Struggled against CB dragons, while Brandish with her power could overpower a full power DG. After current displays, it seems these demons of Faris are not totally strong via scaling.
 
Last edited:
Top