Just to wade somewhat back into this regarding the Buggy argument:
All examples of haki thus far shown have been after direct contact. Luffy's rubber powers were not negated whilst he was standing ten metres from the opponent, but rather in the instant he was actually hit. Kizaru and Aokoji both bled when physically hit, and Smoker was fully formed upon being hit.
So, the case for CoA haki working would be: being hit. (NOTE: this is just a theory, not proven by Oda or anything).
Buggy's fruit, by definition, allows him to not be hit by cutting attacks. Mihawk, Blue Gorilla's, etc have all "cut" him, but he seperates and is not actually hit at all meaning there would be no reaction or feeling of having cut through him. Since he is actually not hit, haki cuts would not work on him.
Of course, that's just a theory. Most likely things will turn out in one of the following ways:
- Mihawk does not have haki, thus Buggy could avoid.
- Mihawk does have haki, but Buggy can avoid (explanation above).
- Mihawk does have haki, and Buggy cannot avoid being cut with haki, but Oda will obviously have to explain this instance else invoking a loophole. Probably something along the lines of Mihawk was not using haki during his two attacks against Buggy.
Those are the scenarios. And though I'm in the "Mihawk should have haki", we do indeed have no proof.