Croc vs Mihawk

who would win

  • Crocodile

    Votes: 19 23.8%
  • Mihawk

    Votes: 54 67.5%
  • can't decide

    Votes: 7 8.8%

  • Total voters
    80

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
Somehow moria from 20 years ago does not strike me as someone who would be exceptionally powerful. Wouldn't he have been a rookie back then? It is possible he was at his peaked 10 years ago when his crew was annihilated and then switched strategies and due to that grew weaker though.
 

Antares

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2008
Messages
109
Reaction score
40
Age
42
Gender
Male
Country
Indonesia
Off-topic:

I don't see how mihawk would have been able to fight vista, a confirmed haki user, without having haki himself.
To me it showed the complete opposite. How would Vista be able to fight Mihawk, the no.1 swordsman in the world, if Mihawk also has haki? Vista wouldn't able to par Mihawk in swordsmanship, so he has to compensate by having something Mihawk don't, or excelling in something Mihawk not excelling in.

In Marineford arc, Mihawk used his vision to detect Luffy's presence and predict Luffy's movement. There's no signs about him having or mastering haki. Buggy didn't die, Jozu's diamond-ness and Croc's logia-ness didn't get pierced through, to me it's enough proof that Mihawk doesn't have it.

Moria, Jimbei, Kuma, they didn't have haki. They are of higher level than Vice Admirals. And they're fine as strong non-haki people.

If haki mastering is abused by Oda by applying it to all high-level opponents, what will be the special weapon of Luffy, which was taught personally by Dark King throughout 2 years, anymore?

But on topic, Mihawk would still beat Croc nonetheless. If Jozu can hurt Croc with his fast movement, Mihawk is surely faster than that.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
We don't know if jimbei or kuma are haki users actually. The manga has neither confirmed nor denied it. jimbei kinda strikes me as a haki user though, I don't see how else his fishman karate would work.

The thing is, I don't think haki was meant to be a special weapon of luffy's nor there is something special in itself about haki. Luffy already has a unique DF and is boosting it with haki. Raileigh already said it, every single human being has haki and it was said it awakens with lots of training and experience. That basically means it is a generic skill among strong people for the most part. As for haki, I don't think it would actually nullify buggy's ability. Buggy's ability is to split himself, it is not quite the same situation as with a logia whose body is not actually being hurt with attacks to begin with. It'd be like saying haki would nullify marco's regenerating ability.
 
Last edited:

Samui

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2008
Messages
555
Reaction score
151
Age
33
Gender
Male
Country
Israel
In Marineford arc, Mihawk used his vision to detect Luffy's presence and predict Luffy's movement. There's no signs about him having or mastering haki. Buggy didn't die, Jozu's diamond-ness and Croc's logia-ness didn't get pierced through, to me it's enough proof that Mihawk doesn't have it.
Mihawk didn't hurt Jozu with Haki because THAT'S NOT HOW HAKI WORKS. You can't bypass a DF defense with a ranged attack like slashes, etc. You need to make contact with the opponent's body.

As for Buggy, maybe Mihawk simply didn't want to kill Buggy? He probably knows he's weak. That's not a proof.
And what about Crocodile? Mihawk never attacked him. He blocked Crocodile's sword and that's it.

Moria, Jimbei, Kuma, they didn't have haki. They are of higher level than Vice Admirals. And they're fine as strong non-haki people.
Moria doesn't have Haki. Jinbei and Kuma probably have it. Jinbei fought Ace for 5 days, he also stopped Akainu's magma with his bare hand, so I guess he used Busoshoku Haki to strengthen his hand.
And even if Kuma does have it, he simply didn't have the change to use it. He didn't need Haki to defeat all of his opponents so far.

If Jozu can hurt Croc with his fast movement, Mihawk is surely faster than that.
That was Haki.
 

Antares

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2008
Messages
109
Reaction score
40
Age
42
Gender
Male
Country
Indonesia
We don't know if jimbei or kuma are haki users actually. The manga has neither confirmed nor denied it. jimbei kinda strikes me as a haki user though, I don't see how else his fishman karate would work.
As for haki, I don't think it would actually nullify buggy's ability. Buggy's ability is to split himself, it is not quite the same situation as with a logia whose body is not actually being hurt with attacks to begin with. It'd be like saying haki would nullify marco's regenerating ability.
Garp punching Marco until he bled and couldn't regenerate, because Garp's haki bypassed Marco's regenerative abilities. Same as WB's backhand which bypassed Akainu's intangibility.

If someone can use haki, it's confirmed by battles mostly immediately, like marco's and vista's against Akainu, it was confirmed by one attack "haki users now?" and Luffy's realization about the mysterious skills Enel, Sentoumaru, and the Snake Sisters. Jimbei, Kuma, and Mihawk were showed battling many times in Marineford arc, but the comments were all about their main skills, sword cutting the glacier, ursus shock, water pole, etc.

If there were events like how Jimbei unable to defend or deflect or pass through against magma attack like Akainu by all of his life like that, he didn't have busoushoku or kebunshoku haki, until proven otherwise. Fishman karate is whole other discipline of skill. Please don't make haki seem like a must and last resort of all favorite characters, it would decrease the fun in One Piece's skill variation greatly. especially using that kind of "not confirmed or denied, so it's still a possibility", because Jimbei or Kuma didn't have it until proven otherwise. And until this point, neither did Mihawk.


Samui,
Moria doesn't have Haki. Jinbei and Kuma probably have it. Jinbei fought Ace for 5 days, he also stopped Akainu's magma with his bare hand, so I guess he used Busoshoku Haki to strengthen his hand.
And even if Kuma does have it, he simply didn't have the change to use it. He didn't need Haki to defeat all of his opponents so far.
There's no panel stating that Jimbei used haki, so Jimbei didn't have it until proven otherwise by others' comment. Kuma didn't need haki? He was winked many times by Ivankov, if eh didn't use haki it means until now he didn't have it.

As for Buggy, maybe Mihawk simply didn't want to kill Buggy? He probably knows he's weak. That's not a proof.
And what about Crocodile? Mihawk never attacked him. He blocked Crocodile's sword and that's it.
It's you that hope that Mihawk or Kuma is too strong yet having pity towards weak chars. But until this point, there's no proof supporting that, so until this moment, Mihawk didn't have it.

That was Haki.
No. Crocodile said it was fast and big.
 

Samui

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2008
Messages
555
Reaction score
151
Age
33
Gender
Male
Country
Israel
There's no panel stating that Jimbei used haki, so Jimbei didn't have it until proven otherwise by others' comment. Kuma didn't need haki? He was winked many times by Ivankov, if eh didn't use haki it means until now he didn't have it.
It wasn't mentioned that Whitebeard used Haki on Akainu, too. It wasn't mentioned that he used Haki during the while war.

Kizaru didn't said anything about Marco's Haki when he kicked him to the ground, so he too didn't use it?

And what does the fact that Kuma was winked by Ivankov has to do with him having Haki or not? Kuma was mindless back then, it might have an effect on his Haki. And so what if he was winked? It did zero demage to him.

And Jozu's attack was fast and he surprised him. That's all. He still hurt him by bypassing his intangibility.

Jinbei stopped Akainu's magma without losing his arm, the same magma that heavily demaged Whitebeard.

Why am I even keeping arguing with you guys.
 

BlackHair

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 10, 2006
Messages
2,503
Reaction score
1,005
Gender
Male
Country
Imperium of Mankind
I don't see how mihawk would have been able to fight vista, a confirmed haki user, without having haki himself.
Haki is just a tool, not some almighty god jutsu. You don't necessarily need haki to to beat another haki user. It's like saying only swordsmen can beat swordsmen, which is wrong.

Jinbei fought Ace for 5 days, he also stopped Akainu's magma with his bare hand, so I guess he used Busoshoku Haki to strengthen his hand.
Jinbei fighting Ace was offpanel and I think there was water nearby, so I wouldn't call that evidence for him having haki. But when did he stop Akainus magma attack? I don't recall such event.

About Mihawk, 'till now there is no hints for him having haki. So until said otherwise, he has no haki.
 
Last edited:

Zehahaha

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Jun 7, 2009
Messages
8,514
Reaction score
5,755
Gender
Male
Country
Morocco
Moria was said to have fought equal with Kaidou. That's the only "fact" we know about it, along with Moria's crew aniquilation. We don't even know if Kaidou's crew was in a better situation. We don't know much about that battle.

But of course that Moria is "too weak for the Shichibukai".
I answered here
 

St Michael

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2010
Messages
166
Reaction score
34
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
France
But when did he stop Akainus magma attack? I don't recall such event.
He prevented one lava punch from hitting luffy , burning his hands in the process .. I don't see any haki in that but .. it did happened.

Zehaha : OK let's imagine that Moria gave a run for his money to Kaidou , but get defeated in the end.. Kaidou and his crew just had to slaughter Moria's. Kinda like Lucci who was going to attack the SH just before Luffy stood up .. that doesn't mean Moria was already a weakass like nowadays.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
To me it showed the complete opposite. How would Vista be able to fight Mihawk, the no.1 swordsman in the world, if Mihawk also has haki? Vista wouldn't able to par Mihawk in swordsmanship, so he has to compensate by having something Mihawk don't, or excelling in something Mihawk not excelling in.
It's simply the same way Akainu confronts the "strongest man" Whitebeard. The difference in strength beetween them is not big.
In Marineford arc, Mihawk used his vision to detect Luffy's presence and predict Luffy's movement. There's no signs about him having or mastering haki. Buggy didn't die, Jozu's diamond-ness and Croc's logia-ness didn't get pierced through, to me it's enough proof that Mihawk doesn't have it.
Have we ever seen the Vice-Admirals "using" Haki?
If haki mastering is abused by Oda by applying it to all high-level opponents, what will be the special weapon of Luffy, which was taught personally by Dark King throughout 2 years, anymore?
The same could be said about Devil Fruit, but the author abused of them already...

We don't know if jimbei or kuma are haki users actually. The manga has neither confirmed nor denied it. jimbei kinda strikes me as a haki user though, I don't see how else his fishman karate would work.
Actually there is some indication. Jinbei fought Ace back them who was a Logia. I would say there are high probablities that Jinbei used his Haki.
Raileigh already said it, every single human being has haki and it was said it awakens with lots of training and experience. That basically means it is a generic skill among strong people for the most part.
Essentially that's it. We saw a lot of characters with it already. I bet it will evolve in something for unique for each characters and creative ways of using it, but for now we don't know much about it.
As for haki, I don't think it would actually nullify buggy's ability. Buggy's ability is to split himself, it is not quite the same situation as with a logia whose body is not actually being hurt with attacks to begin with. It'd be like saying haki would nullify marco's regenerating ability.
Perfect. Haki allow you to touch the real body of a Logia and not to injure the elemental body. Buggy's Devil Fruit works another way.
 
Last edited:

MonsterEnvy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
733
Reaction score
207
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
Actually there is some indication. Jinbei fought Ace back them who was a Logia. I would say there are high probablities that Jinbei used his Haki.
Essentially that's it. We saw a lot of characters with it already. I bet it will evolve in something for unique for each characters and creative ways of using it, but for now we don't know much about it.
Perfect. Haki allow you to touch the real body of a Logia and not to injure the elemental body. Buggy's Devil Fruit works another way.

jinbei was near water so he could just toss some water at ace Logia natrual weaknes the fact that water helps weaken devil fruits (over time) allows jinbei to hurt him

its not just logia it applys to all Devil fruits he said it allows you to hit the body of a devil fruit user even logia
 

St Michael

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2010
Messages
166
Reaction score
34
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
France
Interaction between Haki and DF has yet to be fully explained by Oda , but I tend to agree that if a hit "pass through" Luffy rubber body and is painful , it must cut Buggy like it was a lambda body.

Seems logical to me anyway.
 

bittman

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 8, 2006
Messages
1,746
Reaction score
929
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
Just to wade somewhat back into this regarding the Buggy argument:

All examples of haki thus far shown have been after direct contact. Luffy's rubber powers were not negated whilst he was standing ten metres from the opponent, but rather in the instant he was actually hit. Kizaru and Aokoji both bled when physically hit, and Smoker was fully formed upon being hit.

So, the case for CoA haki working would be: being hit. (NOTE: this is just a theory, not proven by Oda or anything).

Buggy's fruit, by definition, allows him to not be hit by cutting attacks. Mihawk, Blue Gorilla's, etc have all "cut" him, but he seperates and is not actually hit at all meaning there would be no reaction or feeling of having cut through him. Since he is actually not hit, haki cuts would not work on him.

Of course, that's just a theory. Most likely things will turn out in one of the following ways:
  • Mihawk does not have haki, thus Buggy could avoid.
  • Mihawk does have haki, but Buggy can avoid (explanation above).
  • Mihawk does have haki, and Buggy cannot avoid being cut with haki, but Oda will obviously have to explain this instance else invoking a loophole. Probably something along the lines of Mihawk was not using haki during his two attacks against Buggy.

Those are the scenarios. And though I'm in the "Mihawk should have haki", we do indeed have no proof.
 

Lunatic Scream

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2009
Messages
358
Reaction score
203
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Just to wade somewhat back into this regarding the Buggy argument:

All examples of haki thus far shown have been after direct contact. Luffy's rubber powers were not negated whilst he was standing ten metres from the opponent, but rather in the instant he was actually hit. Kizaru and Aokoji both bled when physically hit, and Smoker was fully formed upon being hit.

So, the case for CoA haki working would be: being hit. (NOTE: this is just a theory, not proven by Oda or anything).

Buggy's fruit, by definition, allows him to not be hit by cutting attacks. Mihawk, Blue Gorilla's, etc have all "cut" him, but he seperates and is not actually hit at all meaning there would be no reaction or feeling of having cut through him. Since he is actually not hit, haki cuts would not work on him.

Of course, that's just a theory. Most likely things will turn out in one of the following ways:
  • Mihawk does not have haki, thus Buggy could avoid.
  • Mihawk does have haki, but Buggy can avoid (explanation above).
  • Mihawk does have haki, and Buggy cannot avoid being cut with haki, but Oda will obviously have to explain this instance else invoking a loophole. Probably something along the lines of Mihawk was not using haki during his two attacks against Buggy.

Those are the scenarios. And though I'm in the "Mihawk should have haki", we do indeed have no proof.
Yeah, I was thinking something along these lines for this situation, I'm glad you put it into words.
I also have to say it would be almost criminally silly storywise to have Mihawk not know Haki, even if it hasn't been confirmed yet.

Also it's pretty possible that Mihawk was just curious about Buggy's fruit. He's not a very well known pirate, and it's probably not something he's encountered before.
 

St Michael

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2010
Messages
166
Reaction score
34
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
France
That's not the way I understood Buggy's ability.

I thought that instead of allowing him of being hit by cutting attacks , it made him insensible to cutting attacks.

In other words , Buggy is cut , but doesn't feel any pain , and can "regroup" his body parts.

I may be wrong , if Oda explained the DF ability , I don't remember :oh
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
https://www.cloudmanga.com/One_Piece/527/#9
That is the explanation given in the manga. It does not explain the exact nature of his ability. He is a splitman so cutting and splitting his body does not kill him.
 

damane08

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
688
Reaction score
186
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
https://www.cloudmanga.com/One_Piece/527/#9
That is the explanation given in the manga. It does not explain the exact nature of his ability. He is a splitman so cutting and splitting his body does not kill him.
We all know that but everyone is talking about what happens when he gets cut, not when he separates his parts himself.
The idea that Buggy separates himself right before he gets "cut" makes no sense to me, he does actually get "cut" but all it does is separate that part of his body from the rest. I used to think that he consciously separated his body parts before he gets cut as well... until I saw the little skirmish with Mihawk. Buggy didn't know he was going to get "cut," Luffy grabbed him in an instant and brought him down before Mihawk and before Buggy knew what had happened he was "cut" in two. He definitely didn't separate himself before he was "cut," the cut only separated the top part of his body from the lower part. Don't get me wrong; Buggy can consciously separate his body parts at will but when when Mihawk "Cut" him, there's no way he did that.

the Mihawk thing and I just don't see how he separated himself before he got there.

and even here I don't see how he consciously separated himself here either, heck he even said it himself that he got cut in half.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,475
Reaction score
25,036
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
^BUggy is utterly immune to being cut by others, that is a fact. I don't see why there would be debate about that.
 

St Michael

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2010
Messages
166
Reaction score
34
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
France
XxDrEvilxX : Ok thank you , I wasn't sure.

So , haki should make cutting blows hurt him doesn't it ?

If it's true , either Mihawk doesn't have haki or he didn't use it (but why ?) during the war.

I would prefer that actually. I think the idea of every strong people in OP being haki users kinda lame.

The idea of Mihawk being able to cut through everything (other than DF defense ability obviously) thanks to pure sword mastership sexier.
 

damane08

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
688
Reaction score
186
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
Canada
^BUggy is utterly immune to being cut by others, that is a fact. I don't see why there would be debate about that.
you just don't understand what the debate is actually about...
The important thing to understand is whether or not a sword actually makes physical contact with his body.

If he simply separated himself before he got cut, then even if you imbue haki into your sword and try to cut him, the sword would never make any physical contact with his body and wouldn't be able to harm him.

On the other side of things; if Buggy does not separate himself before he gets cut and a sword forcibly separated his body parts that would mean that a physical connection was made and if that sword had haki imbued in it then that sword should be able to cut Buggy (going by what I understand about haki)


XxDrEvilxX : Ok thank you , I wasn't sure.

So , haki should make cutting blows hurt him doesn't it ?

If it's true , either Mihawk doesn't have haki or he didn't use it (but why ?) during the war.

I would prefer that actually. I think the idea of every strong people in OP being haki users kinda lame.

The idea of Mihawk being able to cut through everything (other than DF defense ability obviously) thanks to pure sword mastership sexier.
Maybe he didn't need it? I don't know if Mihawk knows Buggy's ability (I kinda doubt that he does) the first time he cut Buggy he was actually aiming at Luffy and he didn't really need haki to cut Luffy so maybe he just wasn't using it at the time.

Maybe he doesn't fight all the time with a sword imbued with haki unless he has to.
 
Last edited:
Top