- Joined
- Aug 3, 2006
- Messages
- 4,863
- Reaction score
- 2,841
- Age
- 43
- Gender
- Male
- Country
-
Ok, people, to begin, I’m still shocked with this chapter. I’m not believing on it, it’s too much to bear. This review was the biggest I’ve written in my time here on MH, and I can assure you, I enjoyed so much writing reviews, but more specifically this. Chapter 429 was a chapter, at least, epic. There were so much things I’d like to add to this review, but unfortunately, there isn’t so much time, and the review would get a little boring, too. Please, enjoy the review, and since then, thanks for reading it ^_^
Edited Mangas provided by Sleepyfans
[size=+3]
1º act: Ultimatum
Pain already knows where Naruto is. And he’s aware from Myouboku Mountains as well. Now he’ll head to the mountains, but Tsunade does not have another option if not let him go; after all, the people are the priority. But she was prepared to fight, as her feet were gathering enough chakra to prevent Yahiko’s attack. While is unknown about which strategy she was planning, probably with the chakra she’d stick herself with the ground, preventing the repulsion and attraction.
But Yahiko wasn’t interested in the fight. Rather, he keeps talking about war and peace, just like last week. And with that, everything became clear. Now we know that Pain has another goal other than capture Naruto. Pain is really seeking peace! Granted, he’s using twisted methods in order to achieve it, but the point here is: such development adds more deeply to Pain. His speech comes from a person who has witnessed the horror of war, a victim. And he’s speaking in a sense where he really hates war. A villain that hates war isn’t something you’ll see every day. Sun Tzu, author of The Art of War, writes: while in war, seek peace, and while in peace, seek war. This is exactly what Pain is trying to achieve, as seen in this chapter. Thus, he doesn’t intend to destroy the world, as so many people were suggesting. Remember chapter 418? His last speech in that chapter was: This is nothing compared to the pain this world will suffer. A bit suggestive, huh?
The user The Flash has posted a detailed explanation about Pain’s origins and goals, and with his permission I’ll put it here.
Go to every village and destroying them is not Pain's/Nagato objective.
Let me explain:
Long time ago in narutoverse, villagers wage wars because of land, money, and power. In a result of this desire, innocent people suffer. Nagato/Pain was one of these many innocent people who have suffered.
Nagato/Pain does not want to be the villain; he wants "war" to be the main villain.
He wants the whole world to suffer, and let everyone be in the shoes he was in... So they can finally understand what Pain really is. This intent was showed by Pain to Jiraiya (not the same intent he told to Hidan. In fact it is completely the opposite intent he told Hidan... ah the irony)
How is he going to start wars? The answer is simple. Bijuus. Power is one of the many things people want. It is the desire that people are willing to get in exchange for wars. Pain knows this, and he will give it to them by offering them the power of Bijuu's.
From here on, villages will wage war with other villages, leading to another ninja war. War will continue, and suffering will spread. Once the suffering is so tremendous.... people will finally understand that war was never the solution. But it will be too late, because humanity in narutoverse will lead to almost complete destruction.
Then once the dust is cleared, he will then have peace. It is a very twisted way indeed, but in Pain's eyes, this is retribution.
It was good to see the madness in every word coming from him. His sense of obstinateness with the word “pain” is impressive, as if he named himself after such word, just to be the pain itself. And Tsunade has noticed he’s far more complex than they thought, as his speech clearly implies he’ll make another move. And she wasn’t prepared for what’d come next…
2º act: Prelude
Meanwhile, another person was KIA. Shizune was the victim this time. Human was merciless and ripped-off her soul, even after finding the information. At this point I think it’s impossible to re-attach the soul: we don’t know where’s the soul, or even if there’s some kind of container to place it. Unfortunately, another jounin has fallen…
Back to Naruto, seems he won’t be able to finish the training in time. A frog has said that Kousuke (Jumpy
you aren’t nameless anymore) died, and this means problem. Fukasaku is planning to call Shima (A.K.A. Ma frog) to summon something strong enough to fight or protect Konoha. And whatever was summoned has a scroll, just like Jiraya! There are only a few options available about it: Some unknown frog, bigger and more powerful than Bunta, or Naruto. Of course Jiraya cannot be summoned, he’s dead, and so Minato. The most reasonable choice is Naruto himself. A new year, with a new outfit, suits perfectly for Naruto at this point. Not to mention that every other summoned person, toad, etc, would kill the hype that Kishimoto is building around Naruto’s comeback (and he’s really putting so much effort on it).
And just a little note, but in others translations, seems that two frogs were summoned, along with Naruto. This one makes sense, as the frogs will distract Pain while Naruto gather energy to use with Sage mode.
3º act: Ascension
Suddenly, animal realm beings to retreat, and so hungry realm. Even in a chapter filled with drama like this one, there’s place to some funny moments, like the Kiba’s comments about his parents. And in a “Godly” moment, Yahiko ascends to heaven. I’m sure that Kishimoto has drawn this panel to make some comparison with God, which Yahiko claims to be. Ascending to heaven, raising his arms: Usually this is referenced by some religions. And Yahiko is doing that as he thinks of himself as a true God, the God of peace and pain.
After it, all the others bodies were gathered in the outskirts of Konoha, and some interesting details to be discussed. For the first time, a “secondary” Pain –in this case animal realm- was talking as if she was the real one. Pain was about to use an unknown jutsu that would short his lifespan. It’s good to see that even Pain has his weaknesses, though still is unclear how it affects his life. He’s overpowered, indeed, but at least one weakness is necessary in order to give any hope for the good guys. Essentially in this chapter, Pain was really portrayed as a final villain, and I think that even if Yahiko were to be defeated today, Pain still will live, according with the secret. Fact is, all the remaining Pains were turned off, as if Yahiko were using all the combined power of the 6 paths.
And for the first time, Konan refers to Pain as Nagato. There isn’t any more doubts: Nagato is the true Pain, despite some evidences, i.e., this was too obvious to the plot. The question that remains is exactly what happened to Nagato and Yahiko in the past. But this shouldn’t be discussed here, as it will go off topic.
4º act: Punishment
After turning off the others Pain and gathering enough chakra, Yahiko uses a more powerful version of Shinra Tensei. For a moment, silence. And then, destruction, despair. What comes next? Nothingness. In the next panels (arguably one of the most well drawn panels ever seen) the meaning of the word “Apocalypse” was fully explained. An explosion. Possibly the most impressive and shocking scene we’ve ever seen in Naruto: Konoha was devastated by the super Shinra Tensei. The central part of Konoha was totally annihilated. “From ashes to ashes”, this phrase can describe perfectly these panels. Question is, and now? What kind of consequences will come with it? Was this move a good one? The following paragraphs will explain each of these questions.
Yes, the destruction of Konoha was a smart and good move from Kishimoto. Before the chapter, people were wondering what’d come next, with the great cliffhanger from the last chapter. And the explosion was totally unpredictable. No one was expecting to see such thing at this point. At a first moment, Pain destroying Konoha was easily discarded, as it’d be illogical. In the previous chapter Pain was trying to make an alliance, and now he’s destroying it? Not only has the plot still kept unpredictable –as it keeps the attention of the reader, he doesn’t know what expect from the upcoming chapters and events – as well the catastrophic proportions resulted from it. Big events like this one usually impress people, not to mention this was the first time Kishimoto did something like that.another memorable moment was the statues of the Hokages falling apart: Konoha symbol , which represent its will and power, crumbling... too dramatic.
In the previous paragraph, it was mentioned that Pain was being inconsistent with his objectives. Not really. “You’re either with us or against us”. It was mentioned in the last review, but now there’s a practical example: Tsunade refuses the proposal, thus she’s against Pain. There is a perfect context which should be related with the previous chapter: leaders who don’t agree with the enemy must suffer, and so the people. Metaphorically speaking, this nuke was just like retaliation. The mix between the theories of war in the last chapter with the action in this one was perfectly explored, again approaching Narutoverse to the real life (plot-wise). That’s the reason why the events here weren’t illogical: Mass of people is dying. A war takes no prisoners. Simple and sad.
The last panel implies that about 90% or more from Konoha was destroyed. And with that, a wide variety of possibilities is available. That being said, the entire world will be aware from what happened there. Konoha’s militaries forces were cut by half, or even less, which make it totally susceptible to invasions and assaults. Most likely after this chapter Konoha lost the title of strongest village, at least for the time being. One possibility is Danzou and the coup d’état. Now it’s the perfect time for that. Taking a half ruined village and rebuilding it would make people think he’s a true savior, thus accepting him as a leader. Whether is unknown if Tsunade is dead or not (most likely not) , Danzou has a golden opportunity on hands. Not to mention the possibility of the 4ª Great War. Possibly this is the beginning of the war: with the strongest village ruined, the conflicts will come, and the whole world will be affected either. The number of enemies will increase, and soon the world will swallow in a turmoil of despair and madness. I’d risk to say the fourth great war begins today.
Now the focus can change to another place. Since the beginning of the series, there’s some kind of cycle on it: nins accomplish their missions, then return to Konoha to receive more orders. This isn’t a bad thing, but now, it won’t be possible anymore: the nins will be on their own seeing how Konoha isn’t in position to give any orders for now. In the climax of the arc it’s highly unlikely that Kishimoto will show Konoha’s rebuilds, as Pain won’t stop the search. Most likely the readers will see new places, new scenarios, which is good to know more from Narutoverse.
Final act: Armageddon
And what could be worse than a nuke itself? The aftermath. And Haruno Sakura, as a living witness, should treat the countless wounded in Konoha. When the spoilers were posted, it’s said that the guy who posted them almost cried. And with reason, granted. The drama was pushed to its limits in this chapter. This is the first time she is crying that way. She cannot believe on what happened before, and she’s crying and yelling Naruto’s name. He’s possibly the last line of defense; basically, he’s the greatest military power right now. The girl screaming the hero’s name is somewhat common in shounen titles and sometimes boring, but fortunately this doesn’t apply here. The circumstances are completely different: she has lost people close to her, friends, in her homeland. The hospital was crushed and apparently Sakura was the only survivor, thanks to Katsuyu. Too much for a human, if you ask me.
It’s interesting to notice that Sakura is showing some of her feelings toward Naruto in these panels. Naruto is the only hope right now, but Sakura is yelling him because they’ve spent so much time as Team 7, and probably she has the image of Naruto as the kid who would become Hokage someday, but in that time she wasn’t giving credit to his words. And that kid is the one who’s able to save Konoha. And now she’s recognizing him as a true man, a Hokage. This mix of her personal feelings and the desire to save Konoha, entrusting such task to Naruto, was perfect. One of the top 3 dramatics moments (the others were Sasuke crying while remembering Itachi’s last words and Naruto after receiving the news of Jiraya’s death), moments to touch the feelings of the readers, and Kishimoto has succeeded on this task.
Speaking of Katsuyu and the survivors, it’s the only chance for all of them. Assuming it acts like a shield, all the people with Katsuyu were able to survive, but in this case, all the injured will survive, unfortunately...
To finish the masterpiece, another crazy cliffhanger: Something or someone was just summoned in the last panels. And assuming Naruto is the one returning ( as assumed before in the review), there’s another point to be discussed about the chapter: the circumstances where Naruto will return. Again, comparing with other known shounens, like DBZ, the protagonist always come to save the day, preventing any tragedies, always using the same formula, whereas in this chapter, the tragedy already has happened. This is one of the differences that make this chapter unique. Even the strongest hero cannot save everyone…
Now the stage is settled. The post-apocalyptic scenario will hold the fight. Pain and the mysterious person will fight in the epicenter of the catastrophe. The scenario always plays an important role on every fight. And ruined Konoha reminds so much ruined Namekusei. The epicness is just beginning…
[size=+3]
Definitely the best chapter of the year.
Save the best for last. This statement was perfect for the year. A chapter with good amount of plot development, in just one chapter Pain has explained his true goals and has commited the last act, an act that will bring consequences for all the narutoverse. This was a risky move from Kishimoto, of course, but he was able to make the best use of it, shocking almost all the readers with the unthinkable. The destruction of Konoha, who could think of that? The art was superb, top-notch, and the drama too: it almost makes the reader feel all the horrors of the wars.
With this chapter, seems Kishimoto is establishing a new era in the manga, where Naruto will be the one to make the difference. And if it’s his true goal, he’s doing a superb and perfect work.
Edited Mangas provided by Sleepyfans
[size=+3]
Naruto 429 - Pain
[/size]
1º act: Ultimatum
Pain already knows where Naruto is. And he’s aware from Myouboku Mountains as well. Now he’ll head to the mountains, but Tsunade does not have another option if not let him go; after all, the people are the priority. But she was prepared to fight, as her feet were gathering enough chakra to prevent Yahiko’s attack. While is unknown about which strategy she was planning, probably with the chakra she’d stick herself with the ground, preventing the repulsion and attraction.
But Yahiko wasn’t interested in the fight. Rather, he keeps talking about war and peace, just like last week. And with that, everything became clear. Now we know that Pain has another goal other than capture Naruto. Pain is really seeking peace! Granted, he’s using twisted methods in order to achieve it, but the point here is: such development adds more deeply to Pain. His speech comes from a person who has witnessed the horror of war, a victim. And he’s speaking in a sense where he really hates war. A villain that hates war isn’t something you’ll see every day. Sun Tzu, author of The Art of War, writes: while in war, seek peace, and while in peace, seek war. This is exactly what Pain is trying to achieve, as seen in this chapter. Thus, he doesn’t intend to destroy the world, as so many people were suggesting. Remember chapter 418? His last speech in that chapter was: This is nothing compared to the pain this world will suffer. A bit suggestive, huh?
The user The Flash has posted a detailed explanation about Pain’s origins and goals, and with his permission I’ll put it here.
Go to every village and destroying them is not Pain's/Nagato objective.
Let me explain:
Long time ago in narutoverse, villagers wage wars because of land, money, and power. In a result of this desire, innocent people suffer. Nagato/Pain was one of these many innocent people who have suffered.
Nagato/Pain does not want to be the villain; he wants "war" to be the main villain.
He wants the whole world to suffer, and let everyone be in the shoes he was in... So they can finally understand what Pain really is. This intent was showed by Pain to Jiraiya (not the same intent he told to Hidan. In fact it is completely the opposite intent he told Hidan... ah the irony)
How is he going to start wars? The answer is simple. Bijuus. Power is one of the many things people want. It is the desire that people are willing to get in exchange for wars. Pain knows this, and he will give it to them by offering them the power of Bijuu's.
From here on, villages will wage war with other villages, leading to another ninja war. War will continue, and suffering will spread. Once the suffering is so tremendous.... people will finally understand that war was never the solution. But it will be too late, because humanity in narutoverse will lead to almost complete destruction.
Then once the dust is cleared, he will then have peace. It is a very twisted way indeed, but in Pain's eyes, this is retribution.
It was good to see the madness in every word coming from him. His sense of obstinateness with the word “pain” is impressive, as if he named himself after such word, just to be the pain itself. And Tsunade has noticed he’s far more complex than they thought, as his speech clearly implies he’ll make another move. And she wasn’t prepared for what’d come next…
2º act: Prelude
Meanwhile, another person was KIA. Shizune was the victim this time. Human was merciless and ripped-off her soul, even after finding the information. At this point I think it’s impossible to re-attach the soul: we don’t know where’s the soul, or even if there’s some kind of container to place it. Unfortunately, another jounin has fallen…
Back to Naruto, seems he won’t be able to finish the training in time. A frog has said that Kousuke (Jumpy
you aren’t nameless anymore) died, and this means problem. Fukasaku is planning to call Shima (A.K.A. Ma frog) to summon something strong enough to fight or protect Konoha. And whatever was summoned has a scroll, just like Jiraya! There are only a few options available about it: Some unknown frog, bigger and more powerful than Bunta, or Naruto. Of course Jiraya cannot be summoned, he’s dead, and so Minato. The most reasonable choice is Naruto himself. A new year, with a new outfit, suits perfectly for Naruto at this point. Not to mention that every other summoned person, toad, etc, would kill the hype that Kishimoto is building around Naruto’s comeback (and he’s really putting so much effort on it).And just a little note, but in others translations, seems that two frogs were summoned, along with Naruto. This one makes sense, as the frogs will distract Pain while Naruto gather energy to use with Sage mode.
3º act: Ascension
Suddenly, animal realm beings to retreat, and so hungry realm. Even in a chapter filled with drama like this one, there’s place to some funny moments, like the Kiba’s comments about his parents. And in a “Godly” moment, Yahiko ascends to heaven. I’m sure that Kishimoto has drawn this panel to make some comparison with God, which Yahiko claims to be. Ascending to heaven, raising his arms: Usually this is referenced by some religions. And Yahiko is doing that as he thinks of himself as a true God, the God of peace and pain.
After it, all the others bodies were gathered in the outskirts of Konoha, and some interesting details to be discussed. For the first time, a “secondary” Pain –in this case animal realm- was talking as if she was the real one. Pain was about to use an unknown jutsu that would short his lifespan. It’s good to see that even Pain has his weaknesses, though still is unclear how it affects his life. He’s overpowered, indeed, but at least one weakness is necessary in order to give any hope for the good guys. Essentially in this chapter, Pain was really portrayed as a final villain, and I think that even if Yahiko were to be defeated today, Pain still will live, according with the secret. Fact is, all the remaining Pains were turned off, as if Yahiko were using all the combined power of the 6 paths.
And for the first time, Konan refers to Pain as Nagato. There isn’t any more doubts: Nagato is the true Pain, despite some evidences, i.e., this was too obvious to the plot. The question that remains is exactly what happened to Nagato and Yahiko in the past. But this shouldn’t be discussed here, as it will go off topic.
4º act: Punishment
After turning off the others Pain and gathering enough chakra, Yahiko uses a more powerful version of Shinra Tensei. For a moment, silence. And then, destruction, despair. What comes next? Nothingness. In the next panels (arguably one of the most well drawn panels ever seen) the meaning of the word “Apocalypse” was fully explained. An explosion. Possibly the most impressive and shocking scene we’ve ever seen in Naruto: Konoha was devastated by the super Shinra Tensei. The central part of Konoha was totally annihilated. “From ashes to ashes”, this phrase can describe perfectly these panels. Question is, and now? What kind of consequences will come with it? Was this move a good one? The following paragraphs will explain each of these questions.
Yes, the destruction of Konoha was a smart and good move from Kishimoto. Before the chapter, people were wondering what’d come next, with the great cliffhanger from the last chapter. And the explosion was totally unpredictable. No one was expecting to see such thing at this point. At a first moment, Pain destroying Konoha was easily discarded, as it’d be illogical. In the previous chapter Pain was trying to make an alliance, and now he’s destroying it? Not only has the plot still kept unpredictable –as it keeps the attention of the reader, he doesn’t know what expect from the upcoming chapters and events – as well the catastrophic proportions resulted from it. Big events like this one usually impress people, not to mention this was the first time Kishimoto did something like that.another memorable moment was the statues of the Hokages falling apart: Konoha symbol , which represent its will and power, crumbling... too dramatic.
In the previous paragraph, it was mentioned that Pain was being inconsistent with his objectives. Not really. “You’re either with us or against us”. It was mentioned in the last review, but now there’s a practical example: Tsunade refuses the proposal, thus she’s against Pain. There is a perfect context which should be related with the previous chapter: leaders who don’t agree with the enemy must suffer, and so the people. Metaphorically speaking, this nuke was just like retaliation. The mix between the theories of war in the last chapter with the action in this one was perfectly explored, again approaching Narutoverse to the real life (plot-wise). That’s the reason why the events here weren’t illogical: Mass of people is dying. A war takes no prisoners. Simple and sad.
The last panel implies that about 90% or more from Konoha was destroyed. And with that, a wide variety of possibilities is available. That being said, the entire world will be aware from what happened there. Konoha’s militaries forces were cut by half, or even less, which make it totally susceptible to invasions and assaults. Most likely after this chapter Konoha lost the title of strongest village, at least for the time being. One possibility is Danzou and the coup d’état. Now it’s the perfect time for that. Taking a half ruined village and rebuilding it would make people think he’s a true savior, thus accepting him as a leader. Whether is unknown if Tsunade is dead or not (most likely not) , Danzou has a golden opportunity on hands. Not to mention the possibility of the 4ª Great War. Possibly this is the beginning of the war: with the strongest village ruined, the conflicts will come, and the whole world will be affected either. The number of enemies will increase, and soon the world will swallow in a turmoil of despair and madness. I’d risk to say the fourth great war begins today.
Now the focus can change to another place. Since the beginning of the series, there’s some kind of cycle on it: nins accomplish their missions, then return to Konoha to receive more orders. This isn’t a bad thing, but now, it won’t be possible anymore: the nins will be on their own seeing how Konoha isn’t in position to give any orders for now. In the climax of the arc it’s highly unlikely that Kishimoto will show Konoha’s rebuilds, as Pain won’t stop the search. Most likely the readers will see new places, new scenarios, which is good to know more from Narutoverse.
Final act: Armageddon
And what could be worse than a nuke itself? The aftermath. And Haruno Sakura, as a living witness, should treat the countless wounded in Konoha. When the spoilers were posted, it’s said that the guy who posted them almost cried. And with reason, granted. The drama was pushed to its limits in this chapter. This is the first time she is crying that way. She cannot believe on what happened before, and she’s crying and yelling Naruto’s name. He’s possibly the last line of defense; basically, he’s the greatest military power right now. The girl screaming the hero’s name is somewhat common in shounen titles and sometimes boring, but fortunately this doesn’t apply here. The circumstances are completely different: she has lost people close to her, friends, in her homeland. The hospital was crushed and apparently Sakura was the only survivor, thanks to Katsuyu. Too much for a human, if you ask me.
It’s interesting to notice that Sakura is showing some of her feelings toward Naruto in these panels. Naruto is the only hope right now, but Sakura is yelling him because they’ve spent so much time as Team 7, and probably she has the image of Naruto as the kid who would become Hokage someday, but in that time she wasn’t giving credit to his words. And that kid is the one who’s able to save Konoha. And now she’s recognizing him as a true man, a Hokage. This mix of her personal feelings and the desire to save Konoha, entrusting such task to Naruto, was perfect. One of the top 3 dramatics moments (the others were Sasuke crying while remembering Itachi’s last words and Naruto after receiving the news of Jiraya’s death), moments to touch the feelings of the readers, and Kishimoto has succeeded on this task.
Speaking of Katsuyu and the survivors, it’s the only chance for all of them. Assuming it acts like a shield, all the people with Katsuyu were able to survive, but in this case, all the injured will survive, unfortunately...
To finish the masterpiece, another crazy cliffhanger: Something or someone was just summoned in the last panels. And assuming Naruto is the one returning ( as assumed before in the review), there’s another point to be discussed about the chapter: the circumstances where Naruto will return. Again, comparing with other known shounens, like DBZ, the protagonist always come to save the day, preventing any tragedies, always using the same formula, whereas in this chapter, the tragedy already has happened. This is one of the differences that make this chapter unique. Even the strongest hero cannot save everyone…
Now the stage is settled. The post-apocalyptic scenario will hold the fight. Pain and the mysterious person will fight in the epicenter of the catastrophe. The scenario always plays an important role on every fight. And ruined Konoha reminds so much ruined Namekusei. The epicness is just beginning…
[size=+3]
Final Comments
[/size]Definitely the best chapter of the year.
Save the best for last. This statement was perfect for the year. A chapter with good amount of plot development, in just one chapter Pain has explained his true goals and has commited the last act, an act that will bring consequences for all the narutoverse. This was a risky move from Kishimoto, of course, but he was able to make the best use of it, shocking almost all the readers with the unthinkable. The destruction of Konoha, who could think of that? The art was superb, top-notch, and the drama too: it almost makes the reader feel all the horrors of the wars.
With this chapter, seems Kishimoto is establishing a new era in the manga, where Naruto will be the one to make the difference. And if it’s his true goal, he’s doing a superb and perfect work.
