Chapter One Piece Chapter 1199 Discussion

Federicoxxx

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
3,309
Gender
Male
Country
Argentina
What would be interesting would be a Zoro and Sanji vs Luffy battle at the end after Imu is gone.
that is goin to happen like---I wont say next chapter cause i bet in several FLASHBACK CHAPTERS regarding the Void Century-- but IN THE EXACT moment we came back to the main timeline,, you wish will be more than granted.. i predict: Zoro, Sanji, Dorry, Broggy, Hajrudin, Loki and Ratatosk vs Black Nika..

so im more than sure your wish will be granted with interests..
 

Imfamux

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2016
Messages
598
Reaction score
374
Age
36
Country
Brazil
Thanks for the reply. I can appreciate pivot points. But here's what's also true.
Every 3 years, the WG does the Native Hunting Competition. An entire population is wiped out and its enforced by the Marines. GK are there.

God Island-> bombarded by Marines.
Esperia-> Bombarded by Marines.
Elbaf->actually the interesting one because of Killingham being a minion maker.
Correlation is not causation, for in two of your examples, the island is also getting hit by cannonballs. And in Elbaf's case, they arent trying to disappear it. They actually want it to survive.

But to continue with how the WG disappears places.

Robin's hometown-> bombarded by Marines.
Egghead-> bombarded by Marines
Every country hit by the native hunting->navy is there to make sure it can happen.
Every country hit by a buster call-> destroyed.
Lulusia-> hit by a weapon.

My point is that its not the GK. Its the World Government. The GK work as heralds, but its not them that brings the place down. Statistically, its the cannonballs.


--Regarding unusual ways, well that's the fun part! Creativity is unlimited.
Okay if GK uses AConq, I'll give you that. Maybe that's why the Boar Gorosei had the best defenses. At this point, only the Boar Gorosei and maybe Nasujuro are noteworthy as immortals.

But asking about Gunko? Given that she got caught in a block of ice, and given that she got blown up by Usopp's bomb, and given that Killingham and Sommers did nothing after having parts separated. Here we go, (and these are just to illustrate a point of how the one who wins a fight is the one the writer wants to win)... I'll put this part in a spoiler since its just a lot.
1. Doflamingo thread slice into thread balls to capture the severed parts-> throw the part with the head into the ocean.
2. Blackbeard and Caribo, suck them into their bodies and see what happens.
3. Law shambles and takes the heart, while also throwing the head into the ocean.
4. Hancock petrifies if the lust is there.
5. Perona negative hollow to depress her. Astral Projecting Perona would be the worst to deal with. (Needs Law's haki command ability at minimum to dispel, but her Haki while not possessed hasnt been tested. Her armament is non-existant though)
6. Aokiji's ice freezing her.
7. Magellan's worst poison and trap her in a ball of poison.
8. Crocodile's dehydration touch->followed into the simple butchering and restraints.
9. Noro Noro beam and then abuses. (This one requires help, but its a strong crowd-control ability)
10. Caesar's gas, any one. Remove the oxygen. Put her to sleep. Anything.
11. Sugar's Hobby power, again, assuming she can't use the Law method to break an instant touch power. This one is bad because everyone will forget the victims.
12. Bonney ages her.
13. Luffy kicks her too far away.
14. Kuma sends her flying.
(I write all of these out just to illustrate that there's actually a world of potential out there)

And so on. My point is give anyone else initiative, and remove hostages from her, and she's in trouble.
With her lack of active defense, any of these people could get her in the right circumstance. IF Gunko knows how to use Law's method, then I'll give her that. But at the present, that method happened because Law came up against the Yonko. And the Gorosei, currently lament that their comrades don't take their training seriously. Without the ability negation component, many people can mess with Gunko.

Point is, that when you make it comically easy for these guys to get split apart, you actually open up MANY abuses. It's so much that Oda can create any win condition he wants for the future final war fights.
There is a reason the Revos are able to starve the Holy Land. There's a reason GKs didnt contest them taking Kuma. These guys are way more limited and way more vulnerable than suggested.
The GKs always win, and yet, their territory is on fire.

I do agree with that point on the strawhats. . But I also think what happens is that people are too quick to think in terms of serial power escalation and never in terms of how much space the writer gives himself to allow for asymmetric combat and unique conditions.
I'll always remember and celebrate that Franky can one shot vice admirals and Brook can freeze ancient giants. But I'll also remember the powers that fell before them.
Once an enemy is defeated, people think that enemy is somehow devalued. That's just not how it works. When the strawhats are not involved, regular fights are allowed to happen with the proper consequences.

Without the strawhats there, I think Elbaph would have lost the kids. But I also want to point out that Killingham carried this team. He turned a team of three into dozens. Undeniably, he is their MVP. Like really, if Killingham had been at the other places, I would actually agree that the GK are enough to make a country vanish. Especially if Killingham hides.
But Killingham is just a Sugar-class enemy. He's just a plot enabler.
Yes - marines and W.C are there bombarding everything - and this seems another thing - they ofc have much more autorhithy to launch things likely BUTTER Call by themselves easily - so i'll keep with my opinion of power about them - in a short term

And I think all your points are valid !


The World Government "crew" is undoubtedly the most powerful in all the ages - is what B.B is trying so hard to replicate with his own crew - and is the template for every other powerhouse to rule over a peace of water - for a little bit of time - in the world ruled by Imu
 

Tonix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
1,301
Reaction score
648
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
The World Government "crew" is undoubtedly the most powerful in all the ages

Not sure if I really agree with that. They are basically just propped up by Imu.

Having to resort to things like the Pacifista army, the Seraphim, and desperately trying to acquire the Mother Flame and an army of giants kind of points to them not being the undoubted strongest crew.

If they were the undisputed strongest, they wouldn’t have to go around carefully manipulating everything, Imu wouldn’t be a secret, their home base wouldn’t be getting starved out and burned down, and Cross Guild wouldn’t be able to put out bounties on Marines.

Imu is undoubtedly the strongest emperor, but his forces are kind of ass.
 

Federicoxxx

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
3,309
Gender
Male
Country
Argentina
Not sure if I really agree with that. They are basically just propped up by Imu.

Having to resort to things like the Pacifista army, the Seraphim, and desperately trying to acquire the Mother Flame and an army of giants kind of points to them not being the undoubted strongest crew.

If they were the undisputed strongest, they wouldn’t have to go around carefully manipulating everything, Imu wouldn’t be a secret, their home base wouldn’t be getting starved out and burned down, and Cross Guild wouldn’t be able to put out bounties on Marines.

Imu is undoubtedly the strongest emperor, but his forces are kind of ass.
YEAH..no matter how strong you are,, you cant against 30..or 50 kingdoms at the same time... thats why they are gathering crazy resources as..MOTHER FLAME to literally blast to fkin hell whole island... pacifistas--- experiments like seraphims, and of course THEY WANT THE GIANT ARMY AT ANY COST... oh yeah Ancient tech too... as in the mural you can see the whole world along Nika rebelling against them, they are SO SURE they are gonna use the Mother FLAME indiscriminately,, that they know the sea is goin to rise again, thats the reason of the ALCOHOLIC BRIDGES, they plan to destroy so many islands like Lulusia, the sea gonna rise like CRAZY.. when this happens, Imu's wont need to hide anymore, it will be a kind of situation like: YEAH I EXISTS I SIT ON THE EMPTY THRONE AND IF YOU DONT LIKE IM GOIN TO UNLEASH MOTHER FLAME IN YOU...

also im always surprised at HOW EASY Mariejois can be Infiltrated lol... like with Xebec, Sun Pirates, ¿ the last attack by some unknow force?

i mean to be a place SO HIGH, and with so many resources like, MARINES, Gorosei, God Knights, ¿maybe cp forces living there?,, Admirals?..
i guess not all of them are THERE all TIME...BUT IM pretty sure Goros and Gks for sure...
 

costicla

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2007
Messages
706
Reaction score
620
Age
37
Gender
Male
Country
Romania
Hmm, I actually think the children might indeed be captured at this rate, since Imu is there and Luffy doesn't seem to really be himself now. He probably still doesn't have the Nika fruit under control yet, since awakening.
 

Federicoxxx

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
3,309
Gender
Male
Country
Argentina
Hmm, I actually think the children might indeed be captured at this rate, since Imu is there and Luffy doesn't seem to really be himself now. He probably still doesn't have the Nika fruit under control yet, since awakening.
you mean- bad ending?---

Children captured--

Giants forced to comply and become Imu's allies cause they have no other choice

Giants hating Luffy and Crew, cause Luffy gone rogue, besides the WHOLE disaster they bring with them ?
(even toughs Gks were gonna be there disregarding Luffy and co, being on the island or not)

if Imu's got his GIANT ARMY- it will be quite a KEYPOINT in the final war...
 

Tonix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
1,301
Reaction score
648
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
and of course THEY WANT THE GIANT ARMY AT ANY COST...

And are ironically giving Luffy that army via their actions. Or at least were giving him that army before this G6 stuff which might turn into Elbaf holding a grudge against Luffy.


Imu poked the bear with the attack on Elbaf.

If Luffy can be reigned in before doing something unforgivable, Elbaf’s forces are his. He’s got strong ties to both Giant Crews, Saul, and even Loki at this point.
 

Federicoxxx

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
3,309
Gender
Male
Country
Argentina
And are ironically giving Luffy that army via their actions. Or at least were giving him that army before this G6 stuff which might turn into Elbaf holding a grudge against Luffy.


Imu poked the bear with the attack on Elbaf.

If Luffy can be reigned in before doing something unforgivable, Elbaf’s forces are his. He’s got strong ties to both Giant Crews, Saul, and even Loki at this point.
It depends if they take the Kids or not...and How will they react and decide towards that...

the good ending will be,,- Save the kids, so they cant force the giant to serve them, in first place- and better YET being Nika/Luffy the one who get rid of Imu's and the Gks thus "Liberating" Elbaph from that trash--and AUTOMATICALLY The strawhats winning the Alliance from the MOST POWERFUL ARMY ON EARTH..one that can be KEY to tip the Balance on the final war..

for now things doesnt look good-- kids gonna get kidnapped..and the famous "LIBERATOR" might be the one who destroy Elbaph.
 

costicla

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2007
Messages
706
Reaction score
620
Age
37
Gender
Male
Country
Romania
you mean- bad ending?---

Children captured--

Giants forced to comply and become Imu's allies cause they have no other choice

Giants hating Luffy and Crew, cause Luffy gone rogue, besides the WHOLE disaster they bring with them ?
(even toughs Gks were gonna be there disregarding Luffy and co, being on the island or not)

if Imu's got his GIANT ARMY- it will be quite a KEYPOINT in the final war...
Well, I don't think it will go that bad, but it will be a bigger motivation for Luffy and the crew to actually go to the Holy Land and confront the World Government, Luffy might even feel guilty because he couldn't save them.
 

Federicoxxx

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
3,309
Gender
Male
Country
Argentina
Well, I don't think it will go that bad, but it will be a bigger motivation for Luffy and the crew to actually go to the Holy Land and confront the World Government, Luffy might even feel guilty because he couldn't save them.
I always seen MARIEJOIS ARC, as a Must..but in the very very end of Manga,,,like literally AFTER the voyage back from Laughtale and already having or finding the one piece... not before., and then being when the WAR OF WARS,, a World rebellion like have never been seen,, becomes a reality..

next warc will probably be Lodestar,, and Inokizu
 

costicla

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2007
Messages
706
Reaction score
620
Age
37
Gender
Male
Country
Romania
I always seen MARIEJOIS ARC, as a Must..but in the very very end of Manga,,,like literally AFTER the voyage back from Laughtale and already having or finding the one piece... not before., and then being when the WAR OF WARS,, a World rebellion like have never been seen,, becomes a reality..

next warc will probably be Lodestar,, and Inokizu
true, the fight against the World Government should probably take place after the One Piece is found, since Whitebeard kind of already said that all the way back before the timeskip. i guess Imu's time will be up and the other God's Knights will be defeated before they can take the kids.
 

Federicoxxx

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
5,824
Reaction score
3,309
Gender
Male
Country
Argentina
true, the fight against the World Government should probably take place after the One Piece is found, since Whitebeard kind of already said that all the way back before the timeskip. i guess Imu's time will be up and the other God's Knights will be defeated before they can take the kids.
yeah the story is set up straight as an arrow towards LAUGHTALE,, even if everething fail, and the kids are taken,,i SIMPLE CANT SEE THE straw hats making a trip back up to Mariejois just to save the kids.. so even if that happen.. Luffys gonna continue to voyage, with the promise of rescue them, Once he become P.K and find the one piece.. he is goin to feel horrible for failing, and having losing control and become Black Nika, and eeveeeennn worse if the giants also put the Blame on him,..mostly Not for failing the kids, if not for great part of the destruction of the tree, the island, the villages..
(Leaving aside his failure as "The sun god Nika, being a free easy goin liberator",, and merely being a god of destruction...AND EVEN THAT IF THEY KNOW HE DIDNT MAKE IT AT PORPOUSE,,still it will be his fault, and a danger for everyone. nothing will change that.

The thing is..Luffy want it or not (of course NOT) doesnt change the fact,, he become uncontrollable, and dangerous for EVERYONE,, thats pretty daam bad for people who was seeing you as,, a HOPE, or a God of Liberation, someone who can free the world from WG Tyranny.. is useless if you cant control yourself, and start destroying even your allies.

it is sad to know the PURE GOD, THE FULL ZOAN, THE TRUE NATURE OF NIKA,it is so daam dangerous and Wild.... the Sun God,, the one who need to free the world, NEED TO STAY IN G5,, or whateaver shape, his user full control as a human being.
 
Last edited:

Tonix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
1,301
Reaction score
648
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
It depends if they take the Kids or not...and How will they react and decide towards that...
Kind of feels like the giants are pissed off enough to fight whoever takes their kids instead of becoming slaves at this point.
 
Top