I think (?) the first attempt was by Arjuna/Lawl/Lambs/me (operation Aigoo ) but the jury is out whether or not that was uh useful? successful even? I think it was a game hosted by Vindo and Spirit
I think Vandred‘s game was even before that, I believe first recorded usage of codes was in MG55 Overwatch game, where Vandred proposed a way for their newbie Lambu Janitor to let him and gnut know the killed player‘s role during the day. Greg was like „idk anything about that m8“ when Vand proposed codes, good stuff.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Then again I feel codes are a rather minor thing for playing Mafia, even obsolete without Det/Janitor. I‘ll check on my 4 worst mafia enemies.
Checking back who to nominate reminded me of how I don't recall the last time @Copy Panda was mafia wtf.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Okay so this one's harder for me to pick than Best Town, as Mafia needs a lot more than just the posting we publicly see and night actions but the private discussions that lead to both the night actions and the daytime plays. Though they are private chats, so best I can do is judge their daytime performance, how well they deal with the unexpected, how convincingly they claim roles/actions, how hard to lynch they are and ofc if they can win the game with all those qualities, because unlike as Town as Mafia you have more... "agency" in whether you take the win home or not, or at least that's how it feels.
From both when I played and when I hosted, I believe the best 4 mafias we have are...uhhhh, among these people:
digitaldude
Gajeel
Holt
Lambu
James Rye
gnut
Juviii
Vandred
Gryffindor
xi0
Farfalla
To make things easier on me, I'll nominate whoever isn't already nominated: @digitaldude@Gajeel@Juviii and adding @Ustegius if he isn't already nominated, who hasn't played in forever but he was mafia the first game I hosted and he played very well from what I remember.
Getting tunneled on day 1 but somehow living is bad play?
Well, I think I remember deciding to be a massive asshole (more than usual) that game as some sort of retaliation for it. This was back when my head was on the chopping block every Day 1 I played I think.
My team as insanely scuffed too... so that also was a factor